Ethnopolitics as Co‑operation and Coexistence: The Case‑Study of the Jewish Autonomous Region in Siberia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12797/Politeja.12.2015.31_2.09Keywords:
Jewish Autonomous Region (JAR), post‑Soviet Russia, Birobidzhan, interethnic relations, SiberiaAbstract
It would be a mistake to assume that ethnopolitics is only a matter of confrontation between different ethnic groups. On the contrary, there is a range of examples where it is pursued in a spirit of compromise and co‑operation. One of them is the case of the Jewish Autonomous Region of Birobidzhan, in Post‑Soviet Russia. Often ethnic groups realize that co‑operation and cultural coexistence are more profitable than conflict. Beginning in 1928 the Soviet Union set aside a territory the size of Belgium for Jewish settlement, located some five thousands miles east of Moscow along the Soviet‑Chinese border. Believing that Soviet Jewish people, like other national minorities, deserved a territorial homeland, the regime decided to settle an enclave that would become the Jewish Autonomous Region in 1934. In fact, the establishment of the JAR was the first instance of an officially acknowledged Jewish national territory since ancient times. But the history of the Region was tragic and the experiment failed dismally. Nevertheless, Birobidzhan’s renewed existence of today is not only a curious legacy of Soviet national policy, but after the break‑up of the Soviet Union and the definite religious rebirth, represents an interesting case‑study in respect to interethnic relations.
Downloads
References
Abramsky Ch., ‘The Biro‑Bidzhan Project, 1927‑1959’ in Kochan L. (ed.), The Jews in Soviet Russia since 1917, London 1972.
View in Google Scholar
Alba R., Nee V., ‘Rethinking Assimilation Theory for a New Era of Immigration’, International Migration Review, Vol. 31, No. 4 (1997), at <http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2547416>.
View in Google Scholar
Alberton M., Birobidzhan, die Judenrepublik, Leipzig 1932.
View in Google Scholar
Allain A., Dupont M., Hearn M. (eds.), Les Fédéralismes, Lille 1996 (Collection UL3. Travaux et Recherches).
View in Google Scholar
Arnovitz B., ‘Zion in Siberia’, Survey, Vol. 29, No. 3 (1985).
View in Google Scholar
Aronson I.M., Troubled Waters. The Origins of the 1881 Anti‑Jewish Pogroms in Russia, Pittsburgh 1990 (Series in Russian and East European Studies, 13).
View in Google Scholar
Baron S.W., The Russian Jew under Tsars and Soviets, New York 1964 (Russian Civilization Series, 4).
View in Google Scholar
Bassani L.M., Stewart W.H., Vitale A., I concetti del federalismo, Milano 1995 (Arcana Imperii).
View in Google Scholar
Bauman Z., La società dell’incertezza, Bologna 1999 (Intersezioni, 193).
View in Google Scholar
Baumgarten J., Le yiddish, Paris 1990 (Que sais‑je?, 2552). (Trad. ital.: Giuntina, Firenze 1992).
View in Google Scholar
Beaud O., ‘La Fédération entre l’Etat et l’Empire’ in A. Allain, M. Dupont, M. Hearn (eds.), Les Fédéralismes, Lille 1996 (Collection UL3. Travaux et Recherches).
View in Google Scholar
Brenner F., A Moment Before. Jews in the Soviet Union, New York 1992.
View in Google Scholar
Bromley Yu.V., ‘Towards a Typology of Ethnic Processes’, British Journal of Sociology, Vol. 30, No. 3 (1979), at <http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/589912>.
View in Google Scholar
Brym R.J., The Jews of Moscow, Kiev, and Minsk. Identity, Antisemitism, Emigration, New York 1994. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-13515-8
View in Google Scholar
Cang J., The Silent Millions. A History of the Jews in the Soviet Union, New York 1969.
View in Google Scholar
Clark S.L., Graham D.R., ‘The Russian Federation’s Fight for Survival’, Orbis. A Journal of World Affairs, Vol. 39, No. 3 (1995), at <http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0030‑4387(95)90036‑5>.
View in Google Scholar
Connor W., Ethnonationalism. The Quest for Understanding, Princeton 1994. (Trad. ital: Etnonazionalismo. Quando e perchè emergono le nazioni, Bari 1995 (Nuova Biblioteca Dedalo, 173)). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9780691186962
View in Google Scholar
Conquest R., The Harvest of Sorrow. Soviet Collectivization and the Terror‑Famine, New York 1986.
View in Google Scholar
La Costituzione della Federazione russa, introd., transl. and ed. by A. Vitale, Milano 1994.
View in Google Scholar
Duchacek I., Comparative Federalism. The Territorial Dimension of Politics, Lanham (MD) 1987 (Constitutional Government in Theory and Practice).
View in Google Scholar
Elazar D.J., Exploring Federalism, Tuscaloosa 1987. (Trad. ital.: Idee e forme del federalismo, Milano 1995 (Il Mondo Nuovo)).
View in Google Scholar
Emiot I., The Birobidzhan Affair. A Yiddish Writer in Siberia, trans. by M. Rosenfeld, Philadelphia 1981.
View in Google Scholar
Esman M.J., Ethnic Politics, Ithaca 1994. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7591/9781501723971
View in Google Scholar
Gilboa Y., The Black Years of Soviet Jewry, 1939‑1953, trans. by Y. Shachter, D. Ben‑Abba Boston 1971.
View in Google Scholar
Gitelman Z., Assimilation, Acculturation and National Consciousness among Soviet Jews, New York 1973.
View in Google Scholar
Gitelman Z., ‘The Evolution of Jewish Culture and Identity in the Soviet Union’ in Y. Ro’i, A. Berker (eds.), Jewish Culture and Identity in the Soviet Union, New York 1991.
View in Google Scholar
Gitelman Z., ‘The Jews’, Problems of Communism, Vol. 16, No. 5 (1967).
View in Google Scholar
Gitelman Z., ‘Nationality and Ethnicity in Russia and the Post‑Soviet Republics’ in S. White, A. Pravda, Z. Gitelman (eds.), Developments in Russian and Post‑Soviet Politics, London 1994. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-23461-5_10
View in Google Scholar
Goldberg B.Z., The Jewish Problem in the Soviet Union. Analysis and Solution, New York 1961.
View in Google Scholar
Goozner M., ‘Jewish Culture Struggles to Revive in Russian Far East’, Chicago Tribune, 30 August 1992.
View in Google Scholar
Kagedan A., The Formation of Soviet Jewish Territorial Units, 1924‑1937, Ann Arbor 1987.
View in Google Scholar
Kagedan A., Soviet Zion. The Quest for a Russian Jewish Homeland, Basingstoke 1994.
View in Google Scholar
Kochan L. (ed.), The Jews in Soviet Russia since 1917, London 1972.
View in Google Scholar
Kolarz W., The Peoples of the Soviet Far East, New York 1954 (Books That Matter).
View in Google Scholar
Kostyrchenko G., Out of the Red Shadow. Anti‑Semitism in Stalin’s Russia, Amherst 1995 (Russian Studies Series).
View in Google Scholar
Kuchenbecker A., ‘Ein “Rotes Palästina” im Fernen Osten der Sowjetunion – die Verbannung einer Idee. Die Auseinandersetzungen um ein autonomes jüdisches Siedlungsgebiet in der frühen UdSSR’, Archiv für Sozialgeschichte, No. 37 (1997).
View in Google Scholar
Levin N., The Jews in the Soviet Union since 1917: Paradox of Survival, New York 1988.
View in Google Scholar
Lvavi J., Hityashvut Hayehudim Bebirobijan. The Jewish Colonization of Birobidzhan, Jerusalem 1965.
View in Google Scholar
Lvavi J., ‘Jewish Agricultural Settlement in the USSR’, Soviet Jewish Affairs, Vol. 1, No. 1 (1971), at <http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13501677108577083>.
View in Google Scholar
Maroney E., The Other Zions. The Lost Histories of Jewish Nations, Lanham (MD) 2010.
View in Google Scholar
Midrasz, No. 6: Birobidzhan wczoraj i dziś (2014).
View in Google Scholar
Nivat A., La République juive de Staline, Paris 2013.
View in Google Scholar
Nosov S., ‘Federalism and Anarchy in Russia Today’ in A. Allain, M. Dupont, M. Hearn (eds.), Les Fédéralismes, Lille 1996 (Collection UL3. Travaux et Recherches).
View in Google Scholar
Park R.E, Burgess E.W., Introduction to the Science of Sociology, Chicago 1921.
View in Google Scholar
Parrish M., The Lesser Terror. Soviet State Security, 1939‑1953, Westport–London 1996.
View in Google Scholar
Pinkus B., The Jews of the Soviet Union. The History of a National Minority, Cambridge 1988 (Soviet and East European Studies). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511523717
View in Google Scholar
Pinkus B., The Soviet Government and the Jews, 1948‑1967.
View in Google Scholar
A Documented Study, Cambridge 1984.
View in Google Scholar
Polonsky A., The Jews in Poland and Russia, Vol. 3: 1914‑2008, Oxford 2011 (Littman Library of Jewish Civilization). DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvv4180c
View in Google Scholar
Rapoport L., The Doctor’s Plot of 1953, Cambridge (Mass.) 1991.
View in Google Scholar
Rapoport L., Stalin’s War against the Jews: the Doctor’s Plot and the Soviet Solution, New York 1990 (The Second Thoughts Series).
View in Google Scholar
Ro’i Y. (ed.), Jews and Jewish Life in Russia and the Soviet Union, Ilford 1995 (Cummings Center Series).
View in Google Scholar
Ro’i Y., Berker A. (eds.), Jewish Culture and Identity in the Soviet Union, New York 1991.
View in Google Scholar
Rotschild J., Ethnopolitics. A Conceptual Framework, New York 1981. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7312/roth91044
View in Google Scholar
Rovner A.L., In the Shadow of Zion. Promised Lands Before Israel, New York 2014.
View in Google Scholar
Schlesinger R., Federalism in Central and Eastern Europe, Westport 1970.
View in Google Scholar
Schnapper D., Juifs et israélites, Paris 1980 (Collection Idées, 423).
View in Google Scholar
Schwarz S.M., The Jews in the Soviet Union, Syracuse 1951.
View in Google Scholar
Sharlet R., ‘The Prospects for Federalism in Russian Constitutional Politics’, Publius. The Journal of Federalism, Vol. 24, No. 2 (1994). DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3330725
View in Google Scholar
Smith A.D., The Ethnic Origins of Nations, Oxford 1986. (Trad ital.: Le origini etniche delle nazioni, Bologna 1992 (Saggi)).
View in Google Scholar
Smith A.D., The Ethnic Revival, Cambridge 1981 (Themes in the Social Sciences).
View in Google Scholar
Soljénitsyne A., Deux siècles ensemble, Vol. 2: Juifs et Russes pendant le période soviétique, 1917‑1972, trans. by A. Kichilov, G. Philippenko, N. Struve, Paris 2003.
View in Google Scholar
Srebrnik H.F., ‘Birobidzhan: A Remnant of History. The Jewish Autonomous Region in the Russian Far East’, Jewish Current (2006).
View in Google Scholar
Srebrnik H.F., Dreams of Nationhood. American Jewish Communists and the Soviet Birobidzhan Project, 1924‑1952, Boston 2010 (Jewish Identities in Post‑Modern Society). DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt1zxsj1m
View in Google Scholar
Srebrnik H.F., Jerusalem on the Amur. Birobidzhan and the Canadian Jewish Communist Movement, 1924‑1951, Montreal 2008 (McGill‑Queen’s Studies in Ethnic History, Ser. 2, 25).
View in Google Scholar
Stalin J.V., Marxism and the National Question (1913), Moscow 1945.
View in Google Scholar
Stephan J.J., A Far Eastern Jewish Homeland, Stanford 1994.
View in Google Scholar
Taylor B.D., State Building in Putin’s Russia. Policing and Coercion after Communism, Cambridge 2011. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511974144
View in Google Scholar
Thubron C., In Siberia, London 2000. (Trad ital.: Ponte alle Grazie, Firenze 2000).
View in Google Scholar
Vaksberg A., Stalin against Jews, trans. by A.W. Bouis, New York 1994.
View in Google Scholar
Vitale A., ‘Birobidzhan: la “Prima Israele”’, Galatea – European Magazine (2005).
View in Google Scholar
Vitale A., ‘Decentramento e autonomia: pratica e conseguenze di un mito obsoleto’, Élites, Vol. 3, No. 2 (1999).
View in Google Scholar
Vitale A., ‘L’evoluzione dei rapporti interetnici nello spazio ex‑sovietico’, Futuribili, No. 1/2 (1998).
View in Google Scholar
Vitale A., El Primer Israel. La increible historia del nacimiento y desarrollo de una región autónoma en un confín siberiano. De cómo el pueblo hebreo se sobrepuso a un experimento de Stalin, trans.
View in Google Scholar
by V. Mascioni, Buenos Aires 2007 (Conversaciones. Monde Diplomatique “El Dipló”, 27).
View in Google Scholar
Vitale A., La Regione ebraica in Russia. Birobidzhan, la prima Israele, Lugano 2005 (Attualità e Studi).
View in Google Scholar
Waldenberg M., Kwestie narodowe w Europie Środkowo‑Wschodniej.
View in Google Scholar
Dzieje, idee, Warszawa 1992. (Trad. ital.: Il Saggiatore, Milano 1994).
View in Google Scholar
Wehler H.‑U., Nationalismus. Geschichte, Formen, Folgen, München 2001 (Beck’sche Reihe, 2169). DOI: https://doi.org/10.17104/9783406692710
View in Google Scholar
Weinberg R., ‘Birobidzhan and Solving the “Jewish Question”: the Making of a Jewish Paeasantry’ in Y. Ro’i (ed.), Jews and Jewish Life in Russia and the Soviet Union, Ilford 1995 (Cummings Center Series).
View in Google Scholar
Weinberg R., ‘Jewish Revival in Birobidzhan in the Mirror of Birobidzhanskaia Zvezda’, East European Jewish Affairs, Vol. 26, No. 1 (1996). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13501679608577817
View in Google Scholar
Weinberg R., ‘Purge and Politics in the Periphery: Birobidzhan in 1937’, Slavic Review, Vol. 52, No. 1 (1993), at <http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2499582>.
View in Google Scholar
Weinberg R., Gitelman Z., Bradley B., Stalin’s Forgotten Zion. Birobidzhan and the Making of a Soviet Jewish Homeland. An Illustrated History, 1928‑1996, Berkeley 1998.
View in Google Scholar
White S., Pravda A., Gitelman Z. (eds.), Developments in Russian and Post‑Soviet Politics, London 1994. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-23461-5
View in Google Scholar
Zaslavsky V., Brym R., Soviet‑Jewish Emigration and Soviet Nationality Policy, New York 1983. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-06436-6
View in Google Scholar
Albats E., Evreiskii vopros, Mosca 1995.
View in Google Scholar
Bacrushin S.V., Kazaki na Amure, Leningrad 1925.
View in Google Scholar
Bruk B.L., Birobidzhan, Moscow 1928.
View in Google Scholar
Bugaenko E., Na beregu Amura. 50 let Evrejskoj Avtonomnoj Oblasti, Moscow 1984.
View in Google Scholar
Chavkin M.P., Evrejskaja Avtonomnaja Oblast’ k svoe pervoj godovshine, Emes 1935.
View in Google Scholar
Dal’nevostochnoe Otdelenie Rossijskoj Akademii Nauk (ed.), Evrejskaja Avtronomnaja Oblast’: Enciklopedicheskij Slovar’, Birobidzhan 1999.
View in Google Scholar
Dal’nevostochnyj Federal’nyj Okrug. Shag v XXI vek, Chabarovsk 2001.
View in Google Scholar
Dikij A.I., Evrei v Rossii i v SSSR. Istoricheskij ocherk, Novosibirsk 1994 (1st ed. New York 1967).
View in Google Scholar
Enciklopedija Chabarovskogo Kraja i Evrejskoj Avtonmnoj Oblasti. Opyt enciklopedicheskogo‑geograficheskogo slovarja, Chabarovsk 1995.
View in Google Scholar
Evreiskaja Avtonomnaja Oblast’, Chabarovsk 1959.
View in Google Scholar
Evreiskoe Istoricheskoe Obshestvo (ed.), Istoricheskie sud’by evreev v Rossii i SSSR: nachalo dialoga.
View in Google Scholar
Sbornik stat’ei, Moskva 1992.
View in Google Scholar
Gol’stejn M., Birobidzhancy na Amure, Mosca 1958.
View in Google Scholar
Kadyshevich M., Birobidzhan – strana bol’shich vozmozhnostej, Mosca 1931.
View in Google Scholar
Koblenz B., Waldheim, Mosca 1934.
View in Google Scholar
Kostyrchenko G., V plenu u krasnogo faraona: politicheskie presledovania evreev v SSSR v poslednee stalinskoe desiatiletie. Dokumental’noe issledovanie, Moskva1994.
View in Google Scholar
Kudish E.J., Stern – zvezda moja zavetnaja, Birobidzhan 2000.
View in Google Scholar
Kurencova G.E., Ocherk rastitelnosti Evrejskoj Avt. Oblasti, Vladivostok 1967.
View in Google Scholar
Leskov N.S., Evrei v Rossii: neskol’ko zamechanii po evreiskomu voprosu. Izd, Mosca 1994.
View in Google Scholar
Merezhin L., Chto takoe Birobidzhan?, Mosca 1929.
View in Google Scholar
RG Dal’inform, Evrejskaja Avtonomnaja Oblast’. Na rubezhe tysjacheletij, Chabarovsk 2001.
View in Google Scholar
Schapiro L., Organizatsija KPSS Evrejskoj Avtonomnoj Oblasti. 1934‑1985, Chabarovsk 1986.
View in Google Scholar
Sergeev O.I., Kazachestvo na russkom Dal’nem Vostoke v. XVII‑XIVvv., Mosca 1983.
View in Google Scholar
Stolberg E.‑M., ‘Birobidzhan: v poiskach evrejskoj rodiny’, Zhurnal Diaspory, No. 1 (1999).
View in Google Scholar
Udovenko V.G., Evrejskaja Avtonomnaja Oblast’, Mosca 1957.
View in Google Scholar
Vaiserman D., Birobidzhan, mechti i tragedija. Istorija EAO v sudbach i dokumentach, Chabarovsk 1999.
View in Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
