Review Process & Reviewers

Peer Review Process

The Editorial Board makes a preliminary assessment of the texts submitted for publication, taking into account relevance of the subject, compliance with general rules for the preparation of scientific articles and meeting basic formal and language requirements. Only those articles that meet the basic principles of publication, that is, they are compatible with the Guidelines for Authors are sent to the reviewers. Texts correct in substance, but not in accordance with the guidelines will be sent to the authors for improvement prior to  their further assessment by the reviewers.

All pre-approved articles are evaluated by two reviewers external to the unit from which the  work originates; at least one of the reviewers is affiliated in a foreign institution other than the nationality of the author of the work to avoid conflict of interest. In disputable cases additional reviewers are appointed. The SAAC editors apply the double-blind review process (anonymity of authors and reviewers). Reviewers are appointed by the Scientific Council, taking into account the principle that the reviewer cannot be dependent on the author. The review is anonymous and confidential. The peers are not allowed to use their knowledge of the manuscript  prior to its publication. The review is in a writing (form) and ends with the statement for the release of the article for publication or its rejection. In the case of conditional admission of the article to publication (the general opinion is positive, but the reviewer points out the need for changes and amendments) the reviewer is required to clearly specify his reservations and conditions for accepting the text for printing.

Review Form: download

The author is notified of the review results  and has the right to respond to the comments. Then he/she is obliged to incorporate the agreed amendments in the text. Updated article is accepted for printing after the revised version has been accepted by the reviewer(s). In the case of minor amendments, their acceptance is  carried out by the Scientific Council. Either positive and n egative reviews and conditionally approving of the text for publication are made available to the authors but with maintenance of reviewer’s anonymity. The names of the reviewers of individual publications are not disclosed; the journal gives to public news list of cooperating reviewers after the new volume of SAAC is officially published.



Reviewers for issue 2020

Zaid A. Aldik (Yarmouk University, Jordan)
Jaime Almansa-Sánchez (Institute of Heritage Sciences, Spain)
Claire Balandier (University of Avignon, France)
Craig Barker (University of Sydney, Australia)
Łukasz Banaszek (Historic Environment Scotland, UK)
Louise Blanke (University of Edinburgh, UK)
Dorota Gorzelany (National Museum in Kraków, Poland)
Steven Edwards (University of Toronto, Canada)
Alexander Fantalkin (Tel Aviv University, Israel)
Ebrahim Karimi (University of Victoria, Canada)
Assaf Kleiman (Leipzig University, Germany)
Kenneth Lymer (Independent researcher)
Alison McQuitty (Council for British Research in the Levant, UK)
Jolanta Młynarczyk (Warsaw University, Poland)
Lynda Mulvin (University College Dublin, Ireland)
Marek Nowak (Jagiellonian University, Poland)
George Nuţu (Gavrilă Simion Eco-Museum Research Institute, Romania)
John Peter Oleson (University of Victoria, Canada)
Ewdoksia Papuci-Władyka (Jagiellonian University, Poland)
Konstantinos Politis (Hellenic Society for Near Eastern Studies, Greece)
Lorna-Jane Richardson (Uniwersity of East Anglia, UK)
Tobias Richter (University of Copenhagen, Denmark)
Gary Rollefson (Whitman College, USA)
Andrzej Rozwadowski (Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań, Poland)
Micaela Sinibaldi (Cardiff University, UK)
Marzieh Sha'rba (Independent researcher)
Joachim Śliwa (Jagiellonian University, Poland)
Alan Walmsley (Macquarie University, Australia)


 

Reviewers for issue 2019

Katarzyna Balbuza (Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań, Poland)
Marcello Barbanera (Sapienza – University of Rome, Italy)
Nathalie Beaux (French Institute for Oriental Archaeology in Cairo, Egypt)
David Ben-Shlomo (Ariel University, Israel)
Eliot Braun (WF Albright Institute of Archaeological Research, Jerusalem, Israel)
Jerzy Ciecieląg (Pedagogical University of Cracow, Poland)
Philippe Collombert (University of Geneva, Switzerland)
Laurent Coulon (École pratique des hautes études, Paris, France)
Vincenzo Fiocchi Nicolai (Pontifical Commission for Sacred Archaeology, Rome, Italy)
Mae Goder-Goldberger (Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer Sheva, Israel)
Tomasz Grabowski (Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland)
Thomas Hikade (The University of Sydney, Australia)
Italo Iasiello (Independent researcher, Italy)
Karl Jansen-Winkeln (Free University of Berlin, Germany)
Alejandro Jiménez-Serrano (University of Jaén, Spain)
Barbara Kaim (Warsaw University, Poland)
Sascha Kansteiner (Humboldt University, Berlin, Germany)
A. Bernard Knapp (Univeristy of Glasgow, UK)
Michał Kobusiewicz (The Institute of Archaeology and Ethnology PAS, Poznań, Poland)
Edyta Marzec (Fitch Laboratory, British School at Athens, Greece)
Pierre de Miroschedji (Paris Nanterre University, France)
Charles Anthony Stewart (University of St. Thomas, Houston, USA)
Joachim Śliwa (Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland)
Anna Tatarkiewicz (Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań, Poland)
Ahmet Tolga Tek (Anadolu Universit, Eskişehir, Turkey)
Laurent Tholbecq (Free University of Brussels, Belgium)
Yann Tristant (Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia)
Edwin van den Brink (Israel Antiquities Authority)
Pierre M. Vermeersch (Catholic University of Leuven, Belgium)
Christian Vonhoff (Ruhr University Bochum, Germany)
Malcolm Wiener (Independent researcher, USA)
Monika Zin (University of Leipzig, Germany)


 

Reviewers for issue 2018

Craig Barker (University of Sydney)
Cecilie Brøns (Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek, Copenhagen)
François de Callataÿ (Royal Library of Belgium, Bruxelles)
Skevi Christodoulou (University of Cyprus, Nicosia)
Laurent Chrzanovski (Lucian Blaga University of Sibiu)
Paweł Ćwiąkała (AGH-University of Science and Technology in Krakow)
Piotr Dyczek (Warsaw University)
Fernando Echeverría Rey (Complutense University of Madrid)
Zbigniew Fiema (University of Helsinki)
Martin Henig (Oxford University)
Aleksandra Klęczar (Jagiellonian University, Krakow)
Piotr Kołodziejczyk (Jagiellonian University, Krakow)
Peter Krentz (Davidson College)
John Lund (National Museum of Denmark, Copenhagen)
Marcin Matera (Warsaw University)
Edoardo Radaelli (independent researcher)
Idit Sagiv (Tel Aviv University)
Nicholas Sekunda (Gdańsk University)
Matthew Simonton (Arizona State University)
Sławomir Sprawski (Jagiellonian University, Krakow)
Miglena Stamberova (independent researcher)


 

Reviewers for issue 2017

Alexander Ahrens (Deutsches Archäologisches Institut, Berlin)
Nikos Akamatis (International Hellenic University, Thermi)
Bettina Bader (Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Vienna)
Katarzyna Balbuza (Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań)
Dávid Bartus (Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest)
Mirosław Barwik (University of Warsaw)
Ina Berg (The University of Manchester)
Marianne Bergeron (Ashmolean Museum, Oxford)
Giorgos Bourogiannis (Museum of Mediterranean and Near Eastern Antiquities Medelhavsmuseet, Stockholm)
Stefano Caneva (Université de Liège)
Krzysztoł M. Ciałowicz (Jagiellonian University, Krakow)
Andrzej Ćwiek (Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań)
Martin Dorka Moreno (Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen)
Kata Endreffy (Museum of Fine Arts, Budapest)
Norbert Franken (Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz)
Carmelo Fernandez Ibañez (Archaeological Museum of Palencia)
Elisabetta Gagetti (Independent Researcher, Milan)
Stan Hendrickx (MAD-Faculty, Genk)
Martin Henig (University of Oxford)
Piotr Jaworski (University of Warsaw)
Zdzisław J. Kapera (Jagiellonian University, Krakow, Emeritus)
Attilio Mastrocinque (Università di Verona)
Agnieszka Mączyńska (Poznań Archaeological Museum)
Andrzej Niwiński (University of Warsaw)
Seth Pevnick (Dartmouth College, Hanover, New Hampshire/Tampa Museum of Art)
Graham Philip (Durham University)
Adrian Stähl (Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts)
Joachim Śliwa (Jagiellonian University, Krakow, Emeritus)
Francesca Tasso (Independent Researcher, Milan)
Anna Trofimova (The State Hermitage Museum, St. Petersburg)
Roux Valentine (Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Paris)
Carina Weiß (Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg)
Yuval Yekutieli (Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva)
Erika Zwierlein-Diehl (Universität Bonn, Emeritus)