The Female Voice and the Crossing of the Boundaries of Scholarship
A Note on the Rahasyam of the Lady from Tirukkōḷūr, with a Complete, Annotated Translation
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12797/CIS.22.2020.01.05Keywords:
Tirukkōḷūr peṇpiḷḷai rahasyam, Śrīvaiṣṇava hagiography, Rāmānuja, women’s literature, Paṉṉīrāyirappaṭi guruparamparāprabhāvam, Mummaṇi rahasyam, Piḷḷai Lokam JīyarAbstract
The Female Voice and the Crossing of the Boundaries of Scholarship: A Note on the Rahasyam of the Lady from Tirukkōḷūr, with a Complete, Annotated Translation
The Śrīvaiṣṇavas are prolific writers, who masterfully used multiple languages for composing works in a range of genres, from commentaries to esoterical works, from devotional poetry to hagiography. But while this community, roughly half of which consists of women, claims equality with a difference for women—which includes the right to liberation at death and to religious, albeit non-Vedic, learning—it hardly seems to have encouraged them to emulate the male authors and produce works of any kind. Despite this attitude, a few female voices, sometimes muffled as they can be, are heard across the centuries. One such voice belongs to Tirukkōḷūr peṇpiḷḷai (“the woman from Tirukkōḷūr,” 12th c.?), who allegedly spoke words betraying her scholarly knowledge, and that, too, to the great Rāmānuja himself. Who this woman—who ventured into the jealously-guarded male domain of scholarship—was, and what her ‘composition’ deals with are the topics of this brief essay.
PlumX Metrics of this article
References
Āṟāyirappaṭi by Tirukkurukai Pirāṉ Piḷḷāṉ. See Pakavat viṣayam.
Bhagavadgītā = Zaehner, R. C. (ed.). 1969. The Bhagavad-Gītā, with the Commentary Based on the Original Sources. London: Oxford University Press.
BhP = Bhāgavata purāṇa = Goswami, C. L. (transl.). 1971. Bhāgavatamahāpurāṇa (Śrīmad), Sanskrit text and English translation. 2 vols. Gorakhpur: Gita Press.
Bhaviṣya purāṇa = Sharma, R. (ed.). 1984. The Bhaviṣyamahāpurāṇa. Introduction, Text, Textual Corrections, and Verse-Index. 3 vols. Delhi: Nag Publishers.
Ciṉṉiyammāḷ rahasyam. See Mummaṇi rahasyam.
DSC = Divyasūricaritam by Garuḍavāhanapaṇḍita = Venkatachari, K. K. A. and T. A. Sampatkumaracarya (eds). 1978. Divyasūricaritam by Garuḍavāhanapaṇḍita With Hindi Rendering by Mādhavācārya. Bombay: Ananthacharya Research Institute.
GPP6k = Guruparamparāprabhāvam by Piṉpaḻakiya Perumāḷ Jīyar = Aiyangar, K. (ed.). 1975 [1927]. Āṟāyirappaṭi Guruparamparāprabhāvam. Triplicane: Cē. Kiruṣṇamācāriār patippu.
Īṭu Bhagavadviṣayam. 1925–30. Śrī Bhagavad-Viṣayam. Tiruvāymoḻi mūlamum āṟāyirappaṭi, oṉpatiṉāyirappaṭi, irupattinālāyirappaṭi, īṭumuppattāṟāyirappaṭi vyākhyānaṅkaḷum, cīyar arumpatavurai, pramāṇattiraṭṭu, draviḍopaniṣatsaṅgati, draviḍopaniṣattātparyaratnāvaḷi, tiruvāymoḻi nūṟ-ṟantāti ivaikaḷuṭaṉ. Ed. by Cē. Kiruṣṇamācāriyār. Tiruvallikēṇi: Nōpil Accukkūṭam.
Kaisika māhātmya. 1973. = Varāhapurāṇ attin̲ Uḷḷīṭā n̲a Kaicika Purāṇ am: Śrī Parācarapaṭṭ ar Aruḷicceyta Viyākkiyān̲attuṭan̲ Kūṭ iyatu. Tirucci: Śrīnivāsam Accakam.
MBh = Mahābhārata = Sukthankar, V. S. et al. 1933–1966. The Mahābhārata. For the First Time Critically Edited. 19 vols. Poona: Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute.
Matsya purāṇa = Jośī , K. and S. L. Nagar (eds). 2007. Matsya Mahāpurāṇ a: An Exhaustive Introduction, Sanskrit Text, English Translation, Scholarly Notes and Index of Verses. Delhi: Parimal Publications.
Mummaṇi rahasyam = Rāmānujaṉ, V. V. (ed.). 2009 (2000). Mummaṇikaḷ rakaciyam (tirukkōḷūrammāḷ, tiruvallikkēṇiyammāḷ, ciṉṉiyammāḷ vārttaikaḷ) muḻu vivaraṇattuṭaṉ. Tiruvallikkēṇi: Śrīraṅkapriyā patippakam.
Mutalām tiruvantāti. See Nālāyirattivviyappirapantam.
Nālāyirativviyappirapantam = Kiruṣṇamācāriyar, C. (ed.). 1903. Āḻvārkaḷ aruḷicceyta nālāyira tivviya pirapantam. Ceṉṉai: Kaṇēca accukkūṭam.
Nāṉmukaṉ tiruvantāti. See Nālāyirattivviyappirapantam.
Pakavat viṣayam. 1993. Tiruvāymoḻi mūlamum, āṟāyirappaṭi, oṉpatiṉāyirappaṭi, paṉṉīrāyirappaṭi, īṭu muppattāṟāyirappaṭi vyakyānaṅkaḷum, cīyar arumpatavurai, pramāṇattiraṭṭu, traviṭōpaniṣatsaṅkati, traviṭōpaniṣattātparyaratnāvaḷi. tiruvāymoḻi nūṟṟantāti ivaikaḷuṭaṉ. Trichy: Śrī Sutarcaṉar ṭrasṭ.
GPP12k = Paṉṉīrāyirappaṭi guruparamparāprabhāvam. See Tirukkōḷūr peṇpiḷḷai rahasyam.
Periyāḻvār tirumoḻi by Periyāḻvār. See Nālāyirattivviyappirapantam.
Perumāḷ tirumoḻi by Kulaśekhara Āḻvār. See Nālāyirattivviyappirapantam.
Perumāḷ Tirumoḻi – Commentary on, by Periyavāccāṉ Piḷḷai = Anandakichenin, S. 2018. My Sapphire-hued Lord, My Beloved. A Complete, Annotated Translation of Kulacēkara Āḻvār’s Perumāḷ Tirumoḻi and Periyavāccāṉ Piḷḷai’s Medieval Maṇipravāḷam Commentary, with an Introduction. Collection Indologie No 136. Pondichéry: EFEO/IFP.
Prapannāmṛtam = Aiyangar, K. (ed.). 1995. Guruparamparai Sāramāṉa Prapannāmṛtam. Vol. 2: Āḻvārkaḷ Ācāriyarkaḷ Caritram. Tirucci: Śrīnivāsam Press.
Rahasyam. See Tirukkōḷūr peṇpiḷḷai rahasyam.
VR = Rāmāyaṇam by Vālmīki (VR).
Sastrigal, K. C. and V. H. Subrahmanya Sastri (eds). 1933. (2nd ed.). Śrīmadvālmīkirāmāyaṇam. Madras: N. Ramaratnam.
Bhatt, G. H., P. L. Vaidya et al. (eds). 1960–1975. The Vālmīki Rāmāyaṇa (The National Epic of India). 7 vols. Baroda: Oriental Institute.
Śrīvacanabhūṣaṇam by Piḷḷai Lokācārya = Rangaswami, J. (ed.). 2006. Śrīvacanabhūṣaṇam of Piḷḷai Lokācārya. Translation and Commentary of MaṇavāḷaMāmuṉi. Critical Evaluation of the Theo-philosophy of the post-Ramanuja Śrīvaiṣṇavism. Delhi: Sharada Publishing House.
Tirukkōḷūr peṇpiḷḷai rahasyam (Rahasyam).
Kiruṣṇamācāryar, Ś. A. (ed.). 2018 (1909). Pūrvācāryarkaḷ aruḷic ceyta āṟāyirappaṭi paṉṉīrāyirappaṭi mutaliya kuruparamparā prapāvam. śrī U. vē. Cē. Kiruṣṇamācāryar svāmi 1909-ām āṇṭu patippitta piratiyiṉ aṭippaṭaiyil maṟupatippu ceyyappaṭṭa nūl. Tiruvaraṅkam: Śrīvaiṣṇavaśrī.
See Mummaṇi rahasyam.
Caṭakōpaṉ, Ku. 2008. Tirukkōḷūrp peṇpiḷḷai irakaciyam. Ceṉṉai: Allayaṉs.
Velukkudi, K. s.d. Tirukkōḷūr Peṇpiḷḷai Rahasyam. Chennai: Dayasindhu Associates [CD].
TNT = Tiruneṭuntāṇṭakam by Tirumaṅkai Āḻvār. See Nālāyirativviyappirapantam.
Tiruppallāṇṭu by Periyāḻvār. See Nālāyirattivviyappirapantam.
Tiruvallikkēṇi peṇ rahasyam. See Mummaṇi rahasyam.
TVM = Tiruvāymoḻi. by Nammāḻvār. See Nālāyirativviyapirapantam.
Tiruvāymoḻi vācakamālai by Tirukōn̲ēritāsyai = Tēvanātāccāri (ed.). 1952. Tiruvāymol̲ai Vācakamālai En̲um Vivaraṇa Catakam. Mukavurai-Aṭikkur̲ippu Mutaliyavaikaḷuṭan̲. Tan͂cāvu̅r: Tan͂cāvu̅r Sarasvati Mahāl Nu̅l Nilaiyam.
Upatēca rattiṉamālai by Maṇavāḷamāmuṉikaḷ and its commentary by Piḷḷai Lokam Jīyar = Varatarājaṉ, M. 2015. Upatēcarattiṉamālai: Piḷḷailokam jīyar aruḷiya viyākkiyāṉamum tamiḻākkamum. Ceṉṉai: Śrī Anant patippakam.
Varāha purāṇa = Śrīhṛṣīkeśa śāstrī (ed.). 1982 (1893). Varāhapurāṇam. Vāraṇāsī: Caukhambā Amarabhāratī Prakāśan.
Veṅkaṭācala māhātmyam = Raghavendran, T. S. (ed.). 2014. Śrībhaviṣyatpurāṇ e Śrīveṅkaṭācalamāhātmyam: Śrī Veṅkaṭā cala Māhātmyam in Ś rī Bhaviṣyat Purāṇ am. Tiruchanur: Śrīman Madhva Siddhānta Onnāhinī Sabhā.
Viṣnudharma purāṇa = Grühnendahl, R. (ed.). 1983–1989. Viṣṇ udharmāḥ : Precepts for the Worship of Viṣṇ u. 3 vols. Wiesbaden: O. Harrassowitz.
Viṣṇu purāṇa = Pathak, M. M. (ed.). 1997. Viṣṇu-purāṇa. The Critical Edition of the Viṣṇupurāṇam. 2 vols. Baroda: Oriental Institute.
VR. See Rāmāyaṇa (VR).
Yatīndrapravaṇaprabhāvam by Piḷḷai Lokam Jīyar = Rāmānujan, V. V. (ed.). 2017 (1992). Śrī piḷḷailokārya jīyar aruḷicceyta yatīndrapravaṇa prapāvam (śrīmaṇavāḷamāmuṉikaḷ vaipavam). Tiruvallikkēṇi: Śrīraṅkapriyā patippakam.
Anandakichenin, S. 2014. On the Non-Vālmīkian Sources of Kulacēkara Āḻvār’s ‘Mini-Rāmāyaṇa’. In: E. Francis and C. Schmid (eds). The Archaeology of Bhakti I: Mathurā and Maturai, Back and Forth. Collection Indologie n°125. Pondichéry: IFP/ EFEO: 249–288.
Buck, W. 2000 (1981). Ramayana. With an Introduction by B. A. van Nooten; Illustrated by Shirley Triest. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass Publishers.
Goldman, R. P. (transl.) 2007 (1984). The Rāmāyaṇa of Vālmīki: An Epic of Ancient India. Vol. I: Bālakāṇḍa. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass Publishers.
Mumme, P. 1988. The Śrīvaiṣṇava Theological Dispute: Maṇavāḷa Māmuṉi and Vedānta Deśika. Madras: New Era Publications.
Narayanan, V. 1994. The Rāmāyaṇa in the Theology and Experience of the Śrīvaiṣṇava Community. In: Journal of Vaisnava Studies, 2 (4): 55–89.
—. 2010. Casting Light on the Sounds of the Tamil Veda: Tirukkōṉēri Dāsyai’s ‘Garland of Words’. In: L. L. Patton. Jewels of Authority: Women and Textual Tradition in Hindu India. Don Mills: Oxford University Press: 122–138.
Ramanujan, A. K. 1992. Talking to God in the Mother Tongue. In: India International Centre Quarterly, 19 (4): 53–64.
Rāmānujaṉ, V. V. 2009 (2000). See Mummaṇi Rahasyam.
Ramesh, M. S. 1996. 108 Vaishnavite Divya Desams: Divya desams in Pandya Nadu. Tirupati: T.T. Devasthanams.
Tamil Lexicon. 1924–1936. Madras: University of Madras.
Velukkudi, K. See Tirukkōḷūr Peṇpiḷḷai Rahasyam (4).
Young, K. K. 1997. ‘Theology does Help Women’s Liberation’: Śrīvaiṣṇavism, a Hindu Case Study. In: S. J. Rosen (ed.). Vaiṣṇavī: Women and the Worship of Krishna. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass: 235–293.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
