More Perspectives on the Late Prehistoric Site of Qiryat Ata
A Rejoinder to Eliot Braun
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12797/SAAC.18.2014.18.18Keywords:
Near Eastern archaeology, Southern Levant, Early Bronze Age, Qiryat Ata, stratigraphic interpretation, archaeological methodologyAbstract
In a recent SAAC article, Eliot Braun (2012) has published a critique of my excavations at the late prehistoric site of Qiryat Ata. Reexamination of a site’s stratigraphy and reinterpretation of archaeological data are welcome, if their purpose is to truly enhance our understanding of the history of the site and thus gain a better understanding of the archaeological periods of its occupation. Such a reevaluation should be based on factual evidence, exacting analysis and the realization that even the same data can and is open to different interpretation. Reexamination of the data would strive to offer accurate and useful conclusions that could substantially augment our perception of the archaeological record and be a catalyst for future research and fruitful collegial discussion among scholars.
The purpose of the following is to address the claims and allegations raised by Braun in his article. While some points of Braun’s critique may have their merit and provide a future basis for discussion, examination of his major points shows them to be basically unfounded.
PlumX Metrics of this article
References
Abu Hamid A. 2010. Qiryat Ata. Hadashot Arkheologiyot Excavations and Surveys in Israel 122. Retrieved from http://www.hadashot-esi.org.il/report_detail_eng.aspx?id=1541&mag_id=117 (status as of Feb. 25th, 2014).
Bankirer R. Y. 2003. Chapter 5: the flint assemblage. In A. Golani, 171-182.
Baruch E., Inbar D. and Uziel J. 2007. Area H at Qiryat Ata. Qama 1, 5*-13*.
Braun E. 1989. The problem of the apsidal house: new aspects of Early Bronze I domestic architecture in Israel, Lebanon and Jordan. PEQ 121, 1-43. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/peq.1989.121.1.1
Fantalkin A. 2000. A salvage excavation at an Early Bronze Age settlement on Ha-Shoftim Street, Qiryat ‘Ata. Tel Aviv 27, 28-60. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/tav.2000.2000.1.28
Faust A. and Golani A. 2008. A community in transition: the Early Bronze Age site of Qiryat Ata as a test case. Tel Aviv 35/2, 215-243. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/tav.2008.2008.2.215
Getzov N. 2006. The Tel Beth Yerah Excavations 1994-1995. (Israel Antiquities Authority Reports 28). Jerusalem.
Golani A. 1999. New perspectives on domestic architecture and the initial stages of urbanization in Canaan. Levant 31, 123-133. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/lev.1999.31.1.123
Golani A. 2003. Salvage Excavations at the Early Bronze Age Site of Qiryat Ata. (Israel Antiquities Authority Reports 18). Jerusalem.
Golani A. 2013a. Rescue excavations at the Early Bronze Age site of Qiryat Ata – Area O. ‘Atiqot 75, 27-60.
Golani A. 2013b. The transition from the Late Chalcolithic to the Early Bronze I in southwestern Canaan – Ashqelon as a case for continuity. In E. Braun and V. Roux (eds), The Transition Late Chalcolithic to Early Bronze Age in the Southern Levant, 95-210. (Paléorient 39/1). Paris. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3406/paleo.2013.5489
Golani A. 2014a. Rescue excavations at the Early Bronze Age site of Qiryat Ata – Area N. ‘Atiqot 79, 11-44.
Golani A. 2014b. Rescue excavations at the Early Bronze Age site of Qiryat Ata – Area S. ‘Atiqot 79, 63-98.
Greenberg R. 2002. Early Urbanizations in the Levant. A Regional Narrative. London.
Khalaily H. 2003. Neolithic pottery. In A. Golani, 220-221.
Paz Y., Shoval S. and Zlatkin O. 2009. Canaanite EB IB ‘Proto-metallic Ware’: the earliest production of ceramic ‘Metallic Ware’ in the Land of Israel. Leiden Journal of Pottery Studies 25, 163-188.
Regev J., Miroschedji P. de, Grenberg R., Braun E., Greenhut Z. and Boaretto E. 2012. Chronology of the Early Bronze Age in the southern Levant: new analysis for a high chronology. Radiocarbon 54/3-4, 525-566. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S003382220004724X
Rowan Y. M. 2003. Chapter 6: the groundstone assemblage. In A. Golani, 183-202.
Segal O., forthcoming. Qiryat Ata – Area T. Hadashot Arkheologiyot Excavations and Surveys in Israel.
Tabar M. A. 2010. Qiryat Ata. Hadashot Arkheologiyot Excavations and Surveys in Israel 122. Retrieved from http://www.hadashot-esi.org.il/report_detail_eng.aspx?id=1396&mag_id=117 (status as of Feb. 25th, 2014).
Wright G. E. 1958. The problem of the transition between the Chalcolithic and the Early Bronze Ages. Eretz Israel 5, 37-45.
Yekutieli Y. 2000. Early Bronze Age I pottery in southwestern Canaan. In G. Philip and D. Baird (eds), Ceramics and Change in the Early Bronze Age of the Southern Levant, 129-152. (Levantine Archaeology 2). Sheffield.
Yekutieli Y. 2001. The Early Bronze Age IA of southwestern Canaan. In S. R. Wolff (ed.), Studies in the Archaeology of Israel and Neighboring Lands in Memory of Douglas L. Esse, 659-688. (SAOC 59). Chicago.
