The Impact of the Poniatowski Gems on Later Gem Engraving
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12797/SAAC.20.2016.20.11Keywords:
gems, intaglios, neo-classical, Poniatowski, receptionAbstract
In the first half of the 19th century, the Prince Stanislas Poniatowski (1754–1833) collection of engraved gems was considered to be one of the most outstanding known assemblages. However, its sale at Christie’s in 1839 was a disaster, as the cabinet turned out to include almost only neo-classical specimens and, thus, half of the gems did not go under the hammer. But these intaglios and cameos, and especially the themes they bear, portray in their beauty an effort to re-create a lost neo-classical world as reflected in the texts of Homer, Vergil, and other ancient authors. In contrary to other works on the Poniatowski gems, this paper focuses not on the collection itself, but on its impact on the later gem engraving. It presents two intaglios from the collection of the National Museum in Krakow. The first presents a scene of Hebe pouring out nectar for Jupiter (with an eagle behind him). The second depicts a crowned snake-god with the incorrect Latin inscription: VOT•SOL•CER. They are faithful copies of two Poniatowski gems. In fact, the first gem testifies to the great contribution of the Poniatowski collection to the reception of Classical culture, while the other is a falsification of the original which reflects a later collector’s aim to possess a ‘Poniatowski gem’.
PlumX Metrics of this article
References
Scherf V., Gercke P. and Zazoff P. 1970. Die Antiken Gemmen in deutschen Sammlugen 3. Herzog Anton-Urlich Museum Braunschweig, Sammlung in Arch. Inst. Der Universitat Göttingen, Staatliche Kunstsammlugen Kassel. Wiesbaden.
Auction, Christie and Manson 1839. A Catalogue of the Very Celebrated Collection of Antique Gems of the Prince Poniatowski, London, 29 April–21 May 1839.
Auction, Sotheby, Wilkinson and Hodge 1883. A Catalogue of Gems, the Property of the Late Samuel Sharp, Esq. F.S.A. F.G.S. Of Great Harrowden Hall, Near Wellingborough, Being Selected Medallions, from the Celebrated Cabinet of the Prince Poniatowski, London, April 5th 1883.
Boardman J. and Scarisbrick D. 1977. The Ralph Harari Collection of Finger Rings. London.
Bonner C. 1950. Studies in Magical Amulets Chiefly Graeco-Egyptian. London, Oxford.
Brandys M. 2009. Nieznany książę Poniatowski. Warsaw.
Bulanda E. 1913. Przyczynek do historyi zbioru gemm Stanisława Augusta. Wiadomości Numizmatyczno-Archeologiczne, 181–184.
Bulanda E. 1947. Archeologia klasyczna. Archeologia 1, 38–39.
Busiri Vici A. 1971. I Poniatowski e Roma. Florence.
Delatte A. and Derchain Ph. 1964. Les intailles magiques gréco-égyptiennes. Paris.
Forrer L. 1907. Biographical Dictionary of Medallists, Coin-, Gem- and Seal-Engravers, Mint-Masters, &c. Ancient to Modern with References to their Works B.C. 500–A.D. 1900, vol. 3 (I–Maz). London.
Fredro-Boniecka M. 1939. Gemmy z podpisami artystów w Muzeum Narodowym w Krakowie. Cz. 1: Gemmy Pilcherów. Wiadomości Numizmatyczno-Archeologiczne 20 (1938–1939), 278–292.
Fredro-Boniecka M. 1949. Gemmy z podpisami artystów w Muzeum Narodowym w Krakowie. Cz. 2: Wiadomości Numizmatyczno-Archeologiczne 21 (1940–1948), 53–84.
Furtwängler A. 1896. Beschreibung der Geschnittenen Steine im Antiquarium. Berlin.
Gesztelyi T. 2001. Gemstones and Finger Rings from Brigetio, Collection of the Kuny Domokos Museum of Tata 6. Tata.
Gołyźniak P. 2013. A problematic cameo with a portrait of Augustus from the collection of Constantine Schmidt-Ciążyński. Notae Numismaticae–Zapiski Numizmatyczne 8, 217–226.
Gołyźniak P. 2013. Monsters, chimeras, masks or gods? SAAC 17, 191–202. DOI: https://doi.org/10.12797/SAAC.17.2013.17.17
Gołyźniak P., Natkaniec-Nowak L. and Dumańska-Słowik M. 2016.
A nineteenth-century glyptic collection in the National Museum in Cracow. The cabinet of Constantine Schmidt-Ciążyński. Journal of the History of Collections 28/1 (March 2016), 85–96. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jhc/fhu056
Gołyźniak P. forthcoming a. Ancient Engraved Gems in the National Museum in Krakow.
Gołyźniak P. forthcoming b. A re-discovered Poniatowski gem in the National Museum in Krakow. Jewellery Studies Online, Spring 2017. DOI: https://doi.org/10.29091/9783954908820
Grandesso S. 2010. Berthel Thorvaldsen (1770 – 1884). Milan.
Hartmann J. B. 1979. Antike Motive bei Thorvaldsen. Studien zur Antikenrezeption des Klassizismus. Tübingen.
Henig M., Scarisbrick D. and Whiting M. 1994. Classical Gems: Ancient and Modern Intaglios and Cameos in the Fitzwilliam Museum. Cambridge.
Kagan J. 2010. Gem Engraving in Britain from Antiquity to the Present with a Catalogue of the British Engraved Gems in The State Hermitage Museum. Oxford. DOI: https://doi.org/10.30861/9781407305578
Kaim-Małecka B. 1993. Catalogue des intailles orientales des musées Polonais. Acta Archaeologica Lovaniensia 32, 59–91.
King C. W. 1885. The Handbook of Engraved Gems. London (2nd ed.).
Kiss Z. 1986. S.v. Atherion-Eros. In J. Pouilloux and N. Yalouris (eds.), LIMC, vol. 3, 272–273. Zurich, Munich.
Kolendo J. 1981. Największy skandal w dziejach badań nad gliptyką antyczną. Kolekcja gemm ks. Stanisława Poniatowskiego. Studia Archeologiczne 1, 81–99.
Korzeniowski J. 1895. Souvenirs du Prince Stanislas Poniatowski. Revue d’histoire diplomatique 9/4, 481–535.
Laska A. 2001a. Gemmy księcia Stanisława Poniatowskiego. Opuscula Musealia 11, 105–121.
Laska A. 2001b. Dwie daktylioteki króla Stanisława Poniatowskiego. In E. Papuci-Władyka and J. Śliwa (eds.), Studia Archaeologica. Prace dedykowane profesorowi Januszowi A. Ostrowskiemu w sześćdziesięciolecie urodzin, 235–242. Krakow.
Maaskant-Kleibrink M. 1978. Catalogue of the Engraved Gems in the Royal Coin Cabinet The Hague. The Greek, Etruscan and Roman Collections. Wiesbaden.
Heing M. and McGregor A. 2004. Catalogue of the Engraved Gems and Finger Rings in the Ashmolean Museum. Vol. 2: Roman. Oxford.
Michalski J. 1983. S.v. Poniatowski Stanisław h. Ciołek (1754–1833). In E. Rostworowski (ed.), Polski Słownik Biograficzny 27/3, 481–487.
Mikocki T. 1988. À la recherche de l’art antique les voyageurs polonais et Italie dans les années 1750–1830. Wrocław, Warsaw, Krakow, Gdańsk, Lódź.
Myśliński M. 2001. Sceny gonitw rydwanów na hipodromie w Konstantynopolu – dwie gemmy w zbiorach Muzeum Narodowego w Krakowie. In W. Bulsza and L. Sadko (eds.), Ars Graeca – Ars Latina. Studia dedykowane Profesor Annie Różyckiej Bryzek, 49–54. Krakow.
Myśliński M. 2006. Gemmy późnoantyczne i bizantyńskie w polskich kolekcjach muzealnych. Biuletyn Historii Sztuki 68/2, 229–233.
Neverov O. 1981. Kolekcje dzieł sztuki dwóch Poniatowskich. Archeologia 32, 47–78.
Osborne D. 1912. Engraved Gems, Signets, Talismans and Ornamental Intaglios: Ancient and Modern. New York. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5479/sil.397546.39088006318893
Pannuti U. 1983. Catalogo della Collezione Glittica Museo Archeologico Nazionale di Napoli, vol. 1. Rome.
Philipp H. 1986. Mira et Magica: Gemmen im Ägyptischen Museum der Staatlichen Museen Preuβischer Kulturbesitz Berlin-Charlottenburg. Mainz.
Pirzio Biroli Stefanelli L. 1991. Le opere di Thorvaldsen nella glittica romana dell’Ottocento. In M. Nykajer and P. Kragelund (eds.), Thorwaldsen, L’ambiente, l’influsso, il mito, 91–100. (Analecta Romana Instituti Danici Supplementum 18). Rome.
Platz-Horster G. 1994. Die Antiken Gemmen aus Xanten. Band 2: im Besitz des Archäologischen Parks/Regionalmuseums Xanten, der Katholischen Kirchengemeinde St. Mariae Himmelfahrt Marienbaum sowie in Privatbesitz. Bonn, Cologne.
Platz-Horster G. 2003. Zeichnungen und Gemmen des Giovanni Callandrelli. In D. Willers and L. Raselli-Nydegger (eds.), Im Glanz der Götter und Heroen. Meisterwerke antiker Glyptik aus der Stiftung Leo Merz, 49–62. Mainz.
Platz-Horster G. 2005. L‘antica maniera. Zeichnungen und Gemmen des Giovanni Calandrelli in der Antikensammlung Berlin. Berlin.
Poniatowski S. A. 1830. Catalogue des pierres gravées antiques de S.A. le Prince Stanislas Poniatowski. Florence.
Poniatowski S. A. 1830–1833. Catalogue des Pierres Gravées Antiques de S.A. le Prince Stanislas Poniatowski, vols. 1–3. Florence.
Prendeville J. 1841. Explanatory Catalogue of the Proof-impressions of the Antique Gems Possessed by the Late Prince Poniatowski, and Now in the Possession of John Tyrrell, Esq: Accompanied with Descriptions ... and Preceded by an Essay on Ancient Gems and Gem-engraving. London.
Prendeville J. and Maginn W. 1841. An Historical and Descriptive Account of the Famous Collection of Antique Gems Possessed by the Late Prince Poniatowski: Accompanied by Poetical Illustrations of the Subjects, from Classical Authors, with an Essay on Ancient Gems and Gem-engraving. London.
Prendeville J. and Maginn W. 1857. Photographic Facsimiles of the Antique Gems Formerly Possessed by the Late Prince Poniatowski, Accompanied by a Description and Poetical Illustrations of Each Subject, Carefully Selected from Classical Authors, Together with an Essay on Ancient Gems and Gem-Engraving. London (1st series).
Prendeville J. and Maginn W. 1859. Photographic Facsimiles of the Antique Gems Formerly Possessed by the Late Prince Poniatowski, Accompanied by a Description and Poetical Illustrations of Each Subject, Carefully Selected from Classical Authors, Together with an Essay on Ancient Gems and Gem-Engraving. London (2nd series).
Rambach H. J. 2014. The gem collection of Prince Stanislas Poniatowski. American Numismatic Society Magazine 13/2, 35–49.
Rambach H. J. forthcoming. The sources of Girometti: the case of a masterwork – his Hebe and Jupiter cameo.
Raoul-Rochette D. 1831. Oeuvres diverses italiennes et françaises d’E.Q. Visconti vol. I, II, III. Journal des Savants, 329–341.
Raoul-Rochette D. 1834. Lettre de M. Raoul-Rochette à M. Schorn, sur quelques noms d’artistes omis ou insérés à tort dans le Catalogue de M. Le Dr Sillig. Bulletin des Sciences Historiques, Antiquités Philologie 18, 148–149.
Reinach S. 1895. Pierres gravées des collections Marlborough et d’Orleans, des recueils d’Eckhel, Gori, Levesque de Gravelle, Mariette, Millin, Stosch, reunites et rééditées avec un texte nouveau. Paris.
Rudoe J. 1993. The faking of gems in the eighteenth century. In M. Jones (ed.), Why Fakes Matter. Essays on Problems of Authenticity, 23–31. London.
Seidmann G. 1999. A genuine fake Poniatowski gem? BABesch 74, 263–270. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2143/BAB.74.0.541757
Spier J. 1992. Ancient Gems and Finger Rings: Catalogue of the Collection J. Paul Getty Museum. Malibu, California.
Śliwa J. (1989). Egyptian Scarabs and Magical Gems from the Collection of Constantine Schmidt-Ciążyński. Warsaw, Krakow.
Śliwa J. 1999. Three magical gems with representations of Chnoubis from the Collection of Konstanty Schmidt-Ciążyński. Notae Numismaticae–Zapiski Numizmatyczne 3/4, 25–30.
Śliwa J. 2014. Magical Gems from the Collection of Constantine Schmidt-Ciążyński and from other Polish Collections. Krakow.
Tassinari G. 1993. Aspetti della glittica dell’Ottocento. Successo di un bassorilievo del Thorvaldsen, La Fucina di Vulcano. AnalRom 21, 243–272.
Tassinari G. 1996. Un bassorilievo del Thorvaldsen: Minerva e Prometeo. La sua presenza nella glittica dell’Ottocento e la collezione Poniatowski. AnalRom 23, 147–176.
Tassinari G. 2013. La figurazione glittica di Leda e il cigno e un cammeo di Giovanni Pichler. Sibrium 27, 456–531.
Tassinari G. 2015. Le pitture delle Antichità di Ercolano nelle gemme del XVIII e XIX secolo/The Paintings of the Antichità di Ercolano in 18th and 19th century Gem-Carving. Naples.
Toelken E. H. 1832. Catalogue des pierres gravées de Son Altesse le Prince Stanislas Poniatowski. Jahrbüher für wissenschaftliche Kritik 2 (39–40), 309–320.
Visconti E. Q. 1829. Osservazioni sul catalogo degli antichi incisori in gemme. Esposizione dell’impronte di antiche gemme raccolte per uso di Sua Eccellenza il Sig. Principe D. Agostino Chigi, Catalogo delle gemme antiche di S. A. il Sig. Principe Stanislao Poniatowski. In G. Labus (ed.), Opere varie. Italiane e francesi, vol. 2, 115–134, 141–333, 372–386, pls. I-XIV.
Wagner C. 2008. A picture-book of antiquity: the neo-classical gem Collection of Prince Poniatowski. In P. Castillo (ed.), Congreso Internacional: Imagines. La Antigüedad en las Artes Escénicas y Visuales, 565–572. Logroño.
Wagner C. 2013. Fable and history: Prince Poniatowski’s neo-classical gem collection. In H. Wiegel and M. Vickers (eds.), Excalibur: Essays on Antiquity and the History of Collecting in Honour of Arthur McGregor, 145–150. Oxford.
Weiß C. 1996. Antike Gemmen in deutschen Sammlungen: die antiken Gemmen der Sammlung Friedrich Julius Rudolf Bergau im Germanischen Nationalmuseum Nürnberg. Nuremberg.
Zwierlein-Diehl E. 2007. Antike Gemmen und ihr Nachleben. Berlin, New York. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110920406
