South Africa and its Dichotomous View on the Interwar Commonwealth Defence
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12797/Politeja.22.2025.97.21Keywords:
South Africa, Union Defence Force, Imperial Defence, Commonwealth, NationalismAbstract
The period between the World Wars is a relatively uncharted area in the study of South African security policy, often overlooked in the wider discussion of the nation’s political and defence strategies. While recent scholarly work has attempted to shed light on this complex area, limitations in primary sources and a lack of a holistic approach have hindered a full understanding of the diverse political forces at play in the Union of South Africa at this time. This study seeks to fill these gaps by scrutinising South Africa’s security policies across these two decades. Utilising a rich array of archival resources, the research meticulously outlines South Africa’s rearmament strategy in the 1930s. It explores the driving factors behind this strategy and its impact on the international arena, especially in terms of diplomatic relations between Pretoria and London and South Africa’s geopolitical position in Africa. Additionally, this research examines South Africa’s ambivalent stance towards involvement in another major conflict, linking this reluctance to the rising tide of Afrikaner nationalism which significantly shaped the nation’s socio-political framework. Overall, this study offers a thorough historical-political analysis to understand how internal and external political forces shaped South Africa’s security policies in the years between the World Wars.
Downloads
References
“Aide-Memoire of a Statement on International Defence Policy Made by the Chief of the Imperial General Staff,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 28 November 1930.
“Biographical Note on the South African Minister of Defence Oswald Pirow,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/28, London, June 1936.
Breckenridge K., “Fighting for a White South Africa: White Working-Class Racism and the 1922 Rand Revolt,” South African Historical Journal, vol. 57, no. 1 (2007), pp. 288-243, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02582470709464719.
“British Commonwealth Defence,” The Round Table, vol. 28, no. 111 (1938), pp. 470-485, https://doi.org/10.1080/00358533808450932.
Brownell J., The Collapse of Rhodesia: Population Demographics and the Politics of Race, New York 2011.
Bull H., “European States and African Political Communities,” in H. Bull, A. Watson (eds), The Expansion of International Society, Oxford 1984, pp. 99-114.
Bull H., The Anarchical Society: A Study of Order in World Politics, New York 2002.
Bull H., “The West and South Africa,” Daedalus, vol. 111, no. 2 (1982), pp. 255-270.
Bull H., “What Is the Commonwealth,” World Politics, vol. 11, no. 4 (1959), pp. 577-587.
Buzan B., “World Society and the English School: An ‘International Society’ Perspective on World Society,” European Journal of International Relations, vol. 7, no. 4 (2001), pp. 423-441.
“Cabinet Meeting 31(34),” The National Archives, CAB 23/79/16, 31 July 1934.
“Canadian Obligation under League (The Times),” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 12 March 1936.
“Captain D.D. Plan’s Report on the Union of South Africa Defence Policies,” National Library of Australia, AIR 9/56, London, 26 April 1935.
“Committee of Imperial Defence: The Cooperation of Colonial Empire in Imperial Defence,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 8 June 1938.
“Conversation between the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs and Hon. O. Pirow,” The National Archives, CAB 24/262/54, London, 12 June 1936.
“Conversation between the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs and Sir Campbell Stuart,” The National Archives, FO 954/10A/32, London, 19 June 1936.
Darwin J., “Imperialism in Decline? Tendencies in British Imperial Policy between the Wars,” The Historical Journal, vol. 23, no. 3 (1980), pp. 657-679.
Darwin J., “The Fear of Falling: British Politics and Imperial Decline since 1900,” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, vol. 36 (1986), pp. 27-43, https://doi.org/10.2307/3679058.
“Defence Policy of Empire (The Times),” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/54, London, 6 February 1935.
“Extract from Record of a Discussion in the Dominions Office Conference Room,” National Library of Australia, DO 7040B/12, 4 June 1935.
Freund B., “South Africa: The Union Years, 1910-1948: Political and Economic Foundations,” in R. Ross, A.K. Mager, B. Nasson (eds), The Cambridge History of South Africa, vol. 2: 1888-1994, Cambridge 2011, pp. 211-253, https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521869836.007.
Geldenhuys D., The Diplomacy of Isolation: South African Foreign Policy Making, Johannesburg 1984.
“General Smuts and Imperial Policy,” The National Archives, CAB 24/140/74, Devonshire, 27 December 1922.
Gillman C., “White Colonization in East Africa: With Special Regard to Tanganyika Territory,” Geographical Review, vol. 32, no. 4 (1942), pp. 585-597.
Grayson R.S., “Imperialism in Conservative Defence and Foreign Policy: Leo Amery and the Chamberlains, 1903-39,” The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, vol. 34, no. 4 (2006), pp. 505-527, https://doi.org/10.1080/03086530600991423.
Gray H.R., “The Sovereignty of the Imperial Parliament,” The Modern Law Review, vol. 23, no. 6 (1960), pp. 647-652.
“Imperial Defence: Statement of Policy of His Majesty’s Government in the United Kingdom,” The National Archives, CAB/24/253/38, London, 1 February 1935.
Ivkovic S.K. et al. Police Integrity in South Africa, London 2020, https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315637068.
Katzenstein P.J. (ed.), “Introduction: Alternative Perspectives on National Security,” in The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics, New York 1996, pp. 1-32
“Letter from a British High Commissioner in South Africa to Sir Harry Batterbee,” National Library of Australia, DO 2040B/18, Pretoria, 20 September 1935.
“Letter from Bodenstein to the High Commissioner for South Africa in London,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, Cape Town, 16 April 1931.
“Letter from Maurice Hankey to Prime Minister Macdonald Describing His Meeting with Prime Minister Hertzog,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, Cape Town, 7 September 1934.
“Letter from Maurice Hankey to the High Commissioner for South Africa,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, London, 5 July 1934.
“Letter from Percivale Liesching to John Harding,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, 18 July 1934.
“Letter from the Acting High Commissioner for the United Kingdom in the Union of South Africa to Malcolm Macdonald, Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/164, Cape Town, 28 May 1936.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for South Africa to J.H. Thomas, M.P.,” National Library of Australia, DO 35/108, Pretoria, 30 October 1934.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for South Africa to Prime Minister Hertzog on the British Air Force Expansion,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 19 July 1934.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for the Union of South Africa,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, Pretoria, 14 August 1934.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for the United Kingdom in South Africa,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/2/9, Pretoria, 5 August 1936.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for the United Kingdom in South Africa to Harry Batterbee,” National Library of Australia, DO 7040B/24, Cape Town, 21 January 1936.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for the United Kingdom to J.H. Thomas, M.P.,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/35, Pretoria, 14 July 1934.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for the United Kingdom to Prime Minister Hertzog,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 13 March 1936.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for the United Kingdom to Prime Minister Hertzog,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 30 April 1936.
“Letter from the High Commissioner for the United Kingdom to the Secretary for External Affairs Bodenstein,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 9 January 1930.
“Letter to Hertzog on the Unity in the Commonwealth,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS9/4/1, Pretoria, 5 June 1937.
McKercher B.J.C., “National Security and Imperial Defence: British Grand Strategy and Appeasement, 1930-1939,” Diplomacy & Statecraft, vol. 19 (2008), pp. 391-442.
“Memorandum by Malcolm Macdonald: Conversation with Mr Pirow about Abyssinia,” The National Archives, FO 954/6A/1969, London, 8 June 1936.
“Memorandum on the Proposed Transfer of a Monitor to the Union Government of South Africa,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/190, 29 June 1936.
“Memorandum on the Question of Neutrality and Secession in South Africa,” National Library of Australia, DO 35/108, London, August 1935.
Minter W., Apartheid’s Contras: An Inquiry into the Roots of War in Angola and Mozambique, Johannesburg 1994.
Mouton A.F., The Opportunist: The Political Life of Oswald Pirow, 1915-1959, Pretoria 2022.
“Note of Conversation with Brigadier Sir Pierre van Ryneveld,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/115, Cape Town, 9 March 1936.
“Notes of a Meeting Held at the Dominions Office,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 5 March 1936.
O’Meara D., Forty Lost Years: The Apartheid State and the Politics of the National Party, 1948-1994, Randburg 1996.
“Paraphrase Telegram from the High Commissioner in the Union of South Africa to the Dominions Office,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/71, Cape Town, 27 April 1935.
Parliament of the United Kingdom, Statute of Westminster, London 1931.
Poley A.P., The Federal Systems of the United States and the British Empire: Their Origin, Nature, and Development, London 1913.
“Record of an Informal Discussion at Admiralty House in Simonstown,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/153, Simonstown, 7 May 1936.
“Paraphrase Telegram from the United Kingdom High Commissioner to Dominions Office,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/257, 2 November 1936.
“Report by Major A.N. Williams of an Interview between the Minister of Defence, Union of South Africa and the Staff Officer,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/18, Cape Town, 5 March 1934.
“Report of Malcolm Macdonald to Sir E. Harding on His Informal Talks with Pirow,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/180, London, 25 June 1936.
“Report of the High Commissioner for South Africa on the Metting of the Committee of Imperial Defence,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 19 March 1931.
“Report of the High Commissioner for South Africa on the Metting of the Committee of Imperial Defence,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 20 April 1933.
“Report on Oswald Pirow’s Visit to London,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/191, London, 1 July 1936.
“Report Prepared by M. Hankey on the Dominions’ Rearmament,” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 1 December 1938.
“Results Anticipated by Mr. Pirow for the Union Defence Force at the End of Five Years Plan,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, London, July 1934.
Shaw T., Ashworth L., “Commonwealth Perspectives on International Relations,” International Affairs, vol. 86, no. 5 (2010), pp. 1149-1165.
“South Africa: Notes by Naval Staff,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, London, 2 August 1934.
Spittal C., “The Transatlantic Romance in North Atlantic Triangle: Narratives of Autonomy and Empire in Canadian Foreign Relations,” in R. Bothwell, J. Daudelin (eds), Canada Among Nations 2008: 100 Years of Canadian Foreign Policy, Montreal 2009, pp. 317-342, https://doi.org/10.1515/9780773575882-016.
“Stacke’s Memorandum on a Lesson of the East African Campaign,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, 18 July 1934.
“Telegram from Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs (Sir Malcolm Macdonald) to Minister of External Affairs (Prime Minister Hertzog),” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 3 March 1936.
“Telegram from the High Commissioner for the United Kingdom to the Dominions Office,” National Library of Australia, DO 6984/218, Cape Town, 19 August 1936.
“Telegram from the Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs to Minister of External Affairs (South Africa),” National Archives of South Africa, BTS 9/4/1, London, 25 April 1928.
“The Military Defence Situation in South Africa,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, London, July 1934.
“The Position in South Africa: Memorandum by the Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs,” The National Archives, CAB 24/189/46, London, 5 October 1927.
Thomas M., “Imperial Backwater or Strategic Outpost? The British Takeover of Vichy Madagascar, 1942,” The Historical Journal, vol. 39, no. 4 (1996), pp. 1049-1074.
Trotter A., “The Dominions and Imperial Defence: Hankey’s Tour in 1934,” The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, vol. 2, no. 3 (1974), pp. 318-332, https://doi.org/10.1080/03086537408582415.
“Union of South Africa: Defence and Defence Forces: Note by Sir Maurice Hankey,” The National Archives, CAB 63/69, Pretoria, 9 September 1934.
van der Waag I., “Smuts’s Generals: Towards a First Portrait of the South African High Command, 1912-1948,” War in History, vol. 18, no. 1 (2011), pp. 33-61, https://doi.org/10.1177/0968344510382605.
Watt D.C., “Imperial Defence Policy and Imperial Foreign Policy, 1911-1939: A Neglected Paradox?,” Journal of Commonwealth and Political Studies, vol. 1, no. 4 (1963), pp. 266-281, https://doi.org/10.1080/14662046308446979.
Żukowski A., “The Union of South Africa towards the Outbreak of the Second World War,” Politeja, vol. 42, no. 3 (2016), pp. 17-31, https://doi.org/10.12797/Politeja.13.2016.42.03.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
