The Case of the Angels: The Relevance of the Research by Classical Scholar John Cuthbert Lawson (1874-1919) on Modern Greek Culture

Authors

  • Michał Bzinkowski Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.12797/CC.18.2015.18.04

Keywords:

Modern Greek literature, Modern Greek folk poetry, demotic songs, Modern Greek folklore, folk eschatology, personification of Death, Byzantine eschatology, Byzantine orthodoxy, reception of Antiquity, John Cuthbert Lawson, angels in Byzantium

Abstract

Case of the Angels: The Relevance of the Research by Classical Scholar John Cuthbert Lawson (1874-1919) on Modern Greek Culture

In my paper I focus on the well-known John Cuthbert Lawson’s study about Modern Greek folklore (1910) and I venture to verify if it may be regarded as a reliable source of information about Greek folk beliefs. I base my argument on the eschatological remarks Lawson made concerning the personification of Death – Charos and his relationship to the Christian Angels. Confronting Lawson’s views and his source material with other similar demotic songs, mainly from the collections he had had access to, I try to show in what way the older collections of folk-songs might have distorted or falsified the eschatological images of Charos and the Angels, and what he overlooked while analyzing the sources. I also shed some light on possible influences of Byzantine orthodoxy on Modern Greek folk tradition to which Greek demotic songs belong.

References

Collections of folk songs:

Abbot G. F., 1900, Songs of modern Greece, Cambridge.

Chasiotis G., 1866, Χασιώτης Γ., Συλλογή των κατά την Ήπειρον δημοτικών ασμάτων, Εν Αθήναις.

Fauriel C. Ch., 1824-1825, Chants populaires de la Grèce moderne, Paris.

Fauriel C. Ch. (ed.), 1825, The songs of Greece, from the Romaic text, trans. Ch. Brinsley Sherridan, London.

Garnett L. M. J., 1888, Greek folk-songs from the Ottoman provinces of Northern Hellas, London.

Hahn J. G. von, 1864, Griechische und albanesische Märchen, Leipzig.

Iatridis Α., 1859, Ιατρίδης Α., Συλλογή δημοτικών ασμάτων. Παλαιών και νέων. Μετά διαφόρων Εικονογραφιών, Εν Αθήναις.

Kanellakis Κ., 1890, Κανελλάκης Κ., Χιακά Ανάλεκτα, ήτοι σύλλογοι ηθών, εθίμων, παροιμιών, δημωδών ασμάτων, αινιγμάτων, λεξιλογίου, ιστορικών και άλλων χειρογράφων, χρυσοβούλλων, σιγιλλίων κλπ., Εν Αθήναις.

Kind T., 1861, Anthologie neugriechischer Volkslieder, Leipzig.

Lagarde P. de, 1886, NeuGriechisches aus Klein Asien, Göttingen.

Legrand É., 1874, Recueil de chansons populaires grecques, Paris.

Lévy M., 1860, Chants populaires de la Grèce moderne, Paris.

Marcellus M. de, 1851, Chants du peuple on Grèce, 2 vol., Paris.

Passow A., 1860, Popularia carmina graeciae recentioris, Lipsiae.

Politis N., 1909, Πολίτης Ν., Ακριτικά άσματα: Ο θάνατος του Διγενή, Εν Αθήναις.

Politis N., 1914, Πολίτης Ν., Εκλογαί από τα τραγούδια του ελληνικού λαού, Εν Αθήναις.

Sakellarios Α., 1891, Σακελλάριος Α., Τα Κυπριακά: Ήτοι Γεωγραφία, Ιστορία και Γλώσσα της Κύπρου από των αρχαιοτάτων χρόνων μέχρι σήμερον, τ. 2, Εν Αθήναις.

Saunier G., 1999, Ελληνικά δημοτικά τραγούδια. Τα μοιρολόγια, Αθήνα.

Schmidt B., 1877, Griechische Märchen, Sagen und Volkslieder, Leipzig.

Tommaseo N., 1842, Canti popolari italiani, corsi, illirici, greci, vol. III, Venezia.

Zampelios S., 1852, Ζαμπέλιος Σ., Άσματα δημοτικά της Ελλάδος: Εκδοθέντα μετά μελέτης ιστορικής περί μεσαιωνικού Ελληνισμού, Κερκύρα.

Secondary literature:

Abbot G. F., 1903, Macedonian folklore, Cambridge.

Alexiou M., [1978], Modern Greek folklore and its relations to the past: The evolution of Charos in Greek tradition, [in:] Proceedings of the 1975 Symposium of modern Greek studies, Oakland, pp. 211-236.

Alexiou M., 1984-1985, ‘Folklore, an obituary’, BMGS 9, pp. 1-29.

Alexiou M., 2002a, After Antiquity: Greek language, myth, and metaphor, Ithaca.

Alexiou M., 2002b, Ritual lament in Greek tradition, rev. D. Yatromanolakis, P. Roilos, Cambridge University Press.

Anagnostopoulos J. S., 1984, Αναγνωστόπουλος Ι. Σ., Ο θάνατος και ο κάτω κόσμος στη δημοτική ποίηση. Εσχατολογία της δημοτικής ποίησης, Αθήνα.

Angold M., 2000, Church and society in Byzantium under the Comneni, 1081-1261, Cambridge.

Baun J., 2007, Tales from Another Byzantium: Celestial journey and local community in the medieval Greek apocrypha, Cambridge.

Beaton R., 1986, ‘The oral traditions of modern Greece: A survey’, Oral Tradition 1/1, pp. 110-133.

Beaton R., 2004, Folk poetry of modern Greece, Cambridge.

Bzinkowski M., 2009, ‘Charos psychopompos? Tracing the continuity of the idea of a Ferryman of the Dead in Greek culture’, Classica Cracoviensia XIII, pp. 17-33.

Bzinkowski M., 2011, ‘Names of the abode of the Dead in modern Greek folk songs’, Živa Antika 61, pp. 101-115.

Danforth L., 1982, The death rituals of rural Greece, Princeton.

Dawkins R. M., 1916, Modern Greek in Asia Minor: A study of the dialects of Siĺli, Cappadocia and Phárasa, with grammar, texts, translations and glossary, Cambridge.

Dawkins R. M., 1942, ‘Soul and body in the folklore of modern Greece’, Folklore 53/3, pp. 131-147.

Dawkins R. M., 1953, Modern Greek folktales, Oxford.

Dyer L., 1891, Studies of the Gods in Greece at certain sanctuaries recently excavated, New York.

Geldart E. M., 1884, Folk-lore of modern Greece, London.

Hamilton G. L., 1912, ‘Modern Greek folklore and ancient Greek religion: A study in survivals by John Cuthbert Lawson’ [Rev.], The American Journal of Philology 33/1, pp. 87-90.

Harisson J. E., 1910, ‘Modern Greek folklore and ancient Greek religion: A study in survivals. By John Cuthbert Lawson’ [Rev.], The Classical Review 24/6, pp. 181-183.

Hartnup K., 2004, On the beliefs of the Greeks: Leo Allatios and popular orthodoxy, Leiden–Boston.

Ibrovac M., 1966, Claude Fauriel et la fortune européenne des poésies populaires grecque et serbe: étude d’histoire romantique, suivie du Cours de Fauriel la Poésie populaire des Serbes et des Grecs, professé en Sorbonne 1831-1832, Paris.

Kakridis J. Th., 1969, ‘John Cuthbert Lawson: Modern Greek folklore and ancient Greek religion: A study in survivals. Foreword by A. N. Oikonomides’ [Rev.], Gnomon 41, pp. 495-499.

Kambouroglou D., 1889, Καμπούρογλου Δ., Ιστορία των Αθηναίων: Τουρκοκρατία: Περίοδος πρώτη, 1458-1687, εκδίδοται υπό Α. Παπαγεωργίου, τ. 1, Εν Αθήναις.

Kosegian Ch., 2010, Κοσεγιάν Χ., Αρχαία επιβιώματα στα νεοελληνικά δημοτικά τραγούδια, Αθήνα. Krueger D., 2006, Byzantine Christianity, vol. III, Minneapolis.

Lambakis S., 1982, Λαμπάκης Σ., Οι καταβάσεις στον Κάτω Κόσμο στη βυζαντινή και στη μεταβυζαντινή λογοτεχνία, Αθήνα.

Mackridge P., 2009, ‘From archaeology to dialectology and folklore: The role of the British School at Athens in the career of R. M. Dawkins’, British School at Athens Studies 17, pp. 49-58.

Meyendorff J., 1979, Byzantine theology: Historical trends and doctrinal themes, New York.

Moore C. H., 1912, ‘Modern Greek folklore and ancient Greek religion by John Cuthbert Lawson’ [Rev.], Classical Philology 7/1 , pp. 108-111.

Moore C. H., 1916, The religious thought of the Greeks: From Homer to the triumph of Christianity, Cambridge.

Parédes A., 1965, ‘Modern Greek folklore and ancient Greek religion: A study in survivals. By John Cuthbert Lawson; new foreword by A. N. Oikonomides’, Journal of American Folklore 78/310, p. 356.

Peers G., 2001, Subtle bodies: Representing angels in Byzantium (The transformation of the classical heritage), Oakland.

Politis N., 1882, Πολίτης Ν., Ο ήλιος κατά τους δημώδεις μύθους, Εν Αθήναις.

Politis Α., 2011, Πολίτης A., Το δημοτικό τραγούδι, Ηράκλειο.

Psychogiou Ε., 2008, Ψυχογιού Ε., «Μαυρηγή» και Ελένη. Τελετουργίες θανάτου και αναγέννησης, Εν Αθήναις.

Rodd R., 1892, The customs and the lore of modern Greece, London.

Rose H. J., 1910, ‘Modern Greek folklore and ancient Greek religion: A study in survivals. By John Cuthbert Lawson’ [Rev.], Folk-Lore XXI, pp. 529-532.

Saunier G., 1972, ‘Le combat avec Charos dans les chansons populaires grecques. Formes originelles et formes dérivées’, Ελληνικά 25, pp. 119-152, 335-370.

Saunier G., 1982, ‘Charos et l’Histoire dans les chansons populaires grecques’, Revue des Études Grecques 95, pp. 297-321.

Schmidt B., 1871, Das Volksleben der Neugriechen und das hellenische Alterthum, Leipzig.

Stathis E., 2004, Στάθης Ε., Ελληνικά δημοτικά τραγούδια. Από τον ομηρικό μύθοκαι τ’ αρχέτυπα σχήματα στους ρεμπέτες της Σμύρνης, της Θεσσαλονίκης και του Πειραιά, Εκδόσεις Ι. Σιδέρης.

Tziovas D. (ed.), 2014, Re-imagining the past: Antiquity and modern Greek culture, Oxford.

Vryonis S., 1978, ‘Recent scholarship on continuity and discontinuity of culture: Classical Greeks, Byzantines, modern Greeks’, [in:] S. Vryonis (ed.), The “past” in medieval and modern Greek culture, Malibu, pp. 237-256.

Downloads

Published

2015-09-13

How to Cite

Bzinkowski, M. “The Case of the Angels: The Relevance of the Research by Classical Scholar John Cuthbert Lawson (1874-1919) on Modern Greek Culture”. Classica Cracoviensia, vol. 18, Sept. 2015, pp. 83-110, doi:10.12797/CC.18.2015.18.04.

Issue

Section

Articles