Much Ado about Nothing
Turning The Global Compact into a Red Herring in Italy and Europe
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12797/Politeja.16.2019.63.11Keywords:
global compact, migration, nationalism, Italy, UNAbstract
The Global Compact for Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration is, as The Economist described it in a recent column by Tom Nuttall, a dull piece of reading. At best, stressed Nuttal, it helps build the trust between sending and receiving countries that is the foundation of any meaningful international policy.Then how did a non-binding, declaratory intergovernmental agreement becamea crucial part of the political discourse in a considerable number of EU countries, effectively leading to the withdrawal of several governments from the Compact? The upheaval caused by the adoption of the Compact (which hadalready been discussed and agreed upon by all signatory governments in July, before becoming a token for nationalist propaganda) has once again demonstrated the inability of the EU to grow towards a sensitive migration policy, and the recklessness of many governments in refusing to engage in a reasonable conversation with other international actors in favour of a political line led by sensationalism and misinformation. The aim of this research paper is to map thedevelopment of the debate over the Global Compact in Italy building up to its abstention during the Marrakesh Conference on December 10th-11th. The research focuses on the main actors of the current political discourse in Italy, their inaccuracy and deliberate ambiguity in addressing concerns over the Compactduring Parliamentary sessions and through the mass media, and the failure of the opposition, together with civil society, to leverage a valid counterargument to the growing hysteria about the migration crisis. The expected outcomes are the identification of common patterns in the nationalist discourse in Italy and the advancement of possible new practices to effectively foster a consistent, level-headed conversation about migration management that steers away from sterile symbolism and responsibly addresses community issues at the national and EU levels.
Downloads
References
Benedetti V., “La trappola del Global Compact. Così aprirà le porte all’invasione”, (2018), Il Primato Nazionale, 27 November 2018, at <https://www.ilprimatonazionale.it/politica/la-trappola-del-global-compact-cosi-aprira-le-porte-all-invasione-97430/>, 5 November 2019.
Bucchi G., “Migranti, cos’è il Global compact dell’Onu: il patto che ci condanna all’invasione”, Libero, 18 November 2018, at <https://www.liberoquotidiano.it/news/esteri/13401156/migranti-global-compact-onu-patto-internazionale-invasione-italia-immigrazione.html>, 5 November 2019.
Gatti M., “EU States’ Exit from the Global Compact on Migration: A Breach of Loyalty”, EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy, 14 December 2018, at <http://eumigrationlawblog.eu/eu-states-exit-from-the-global-compact-on-migration-a-breach-of-loyalty/>, 5 November 2019.
“Global Compact on Migration: the Farnesina meets the Italian civil society”, MAECI, 28 March 2018, at <https://www.esteri.it/mae/en/sala_stampa/archivionotizie/eventi/2018/03/global-compact-migrazioni-la-farnesina-incontra-la-societa-civile.html>, 8 November 2019.
“Global Compact, il Vaticano: sia un passo avanti al servizio non solo dei migranti, ma dell’umanità”, La Stampa, 14 July 2018, at <https://www.lastampa.it/2018/07/14/vaticaninsider/global-compact-il-vaticanosia-un-passo-avanti-al-servizio-non-solo-deimigrantima-dellumanit-T08TxeRXdQ7x0dgyrf863N/pagina.html>, 15 October 2019.
“Hungary is Exiting the Adoption Process of the Global Compact for Migration” (2018), Kormany, 18 July 2018, at <http://www.kormany.hu/en/ministry-of-foreign-affairs-andtrade/news/hungary-is-exiting-the-adoption-process-of-the-global-compact-for-migration>, 5 November 2019.
“Hungary to Quit U.N. Migration Pact Shunned by Washington”, Reuters, 18 July 2018, at <https://www.reuters.com/article/us-europe-migrants-hungary-un/hungary-to-quit-unmigration-pact-shunned-by-washington-idUSKBN1K81BS>, 8 November 2019.
Kovács Z., “‘Security First’: Hungary Responds to the UN with a 12-Point Proposal to Handle Global Migration”, About Hungary, 2 March 2018, at http://abouthungary.hu/blog/security-first-hungary-responds-to-the-un-with-a-12-point-proposal-to-handle-global-migration/, 5 November 2019.
“L’uomo che ha creato il caso ONG”, Il Post, 2 February 2019, at <https://www.ilpost.it/2019/02/02/pietro-gallo-scandalo-ong/>, 5 November 2019.
“La storia dei ‘taxi per migranti’”, Il Post, 27 April 2017, at <https://www.ilpost.it/2017/04/27/taxi-migranti-ong/>, 8 November 2019.
Mattei N., “Immigrazione: cosa vuole fare il governo con il Global Compact?”, Il Primato Nazionale, 26 November 2018, at <https://www.ilprimatonazionale.it/politica/immigrazionecosa-vuol-fare-governo-global-compact-97363/>, 20 October 2019.
Meloni G., “NO al Global Compact, l’ultima fregatura dell’ONU per imporci l’invasione”, Facebook, 16 November 2018, at <https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=403762876828187>, 5 November 2019.
“Migranti, Conte: ‘Non ho cambiato idea sul Global Compact, ma è giusto che decida il Parlamento’”, La Repubblica, 28 November 2018, at <https://video.repubblica.it/dossier/governo-lega-m5s/migranti-conte-non-ho-cambiato-idea-sul-global-compact-ma-e-giusto-chedecida-il-parlamento/320988/321615>, 5 November 2019.
“Migranti, quando Conte assicurò all’assemblea Onu: ‘L’Italia sostiene il Global Compact’”, La Repubblica, 28 November 2018, at <https://video.repubblica.it/dossier/governo-legam5s/migranti-quando-conte-assicuro-all-assemblea-onu-l-italia-sostiene-il-global-compact/320982/321608>, 8 November 2019.
“Migranti: Conte, sospesa adesione a Global compact, non andiamo a Marrakesh”, AGI, 28 November 2018, at <https://www.agi.it/politica/migranti_global_compact_conte_adesione_sospesa-4681918/news/2018-11-28/>, 5 November 2019.
Murphy F., “Austria to Shun Global Migration Pact, Fearing Creep in Human Rights”, Reuters, 31 October 2018, at <https://www.reuters.com/article/us-un-migrants-austria/austria-toshun-global-migration-pact-fearing-creep-in-human-rights-idUSKCN1N50JZ>, 9 November 2019.
Nuttall T., “European Governments in Melt-Down over an Inoffensive Migration Compact”, The Economist, 8 December 2018, at <https://www.economist.com/europe/2018/12/08/european-governments-in-melt-down-over-an-inoffensive-migration-compact>, 8 November 2019.
Sandelind C. (ed.), European Populism and Winning the Immigration Debate, Stockholm 2014.
“Second edition of the conference ‘A Shared Responsibility for a Common Goal – Solidarity and Security’”, MAECI, 6 February 2018, At <https://www.esteri.it/mae/en/sala_stampa/archivionotizie/eventi/2018/02/seconda-edizione-della-conferenza.html>, 5 November 2019.
Storace F., “Migranti, Storace: ‘Perché Salvini tace sul Global Compact?’”, Affari Italiani, 23 November 2018, at <http://www.affaritaliani.it/politica/migranti-storace-perche-salvinitace-sul-global-compact-573768.html>, 8 November 2019.
Villa M., “Italy’s Post-Fact Immigration Debate”, Politico, 27 June 2018, at <https://www.politico.eu/article/italy-immigration-debate-facts-dont-matter/>, 5 November 2019.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.