Nie tylko geopolityka. Relacje rosyjsko-chińskie pod koniec drugiej dekady XXI wieku
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12797/Politeja.15.2018.53.06Keywords:
Russia, China, Sino‑Russian relations, constructivism in international relations, realism in international relations, Axis of ConvenienceAbstract
Beyond Geopolitics. The Sino-Russian Relations in the Late 2010s
Since more than a decade the international (Western) academia has been considering Sino‑Russian relations as an „Axis of Convenience”: a temporarily, shallow, tactical alliance prone to changing circumstances; a one that may turn into antagonism should international situation evolve. This approach reached its climax after Donald Trump’s victory in US Presidential elections in 2016: many believed that there would soon be „a reverse Nixon’s strategy”. The reality has falsified these theses and showed that Sino‑Russian relations have solid foundations. These more stable base of Russia‑China relations was born in late 2000s when Russian ruling elite made a choice and decided that China did not pose a threat to current Russian regime. This elite’s understanding paved a way for current Sino‑Russian rapprochement.
Downloads
References
Acharya A., A Concert of Asia?, „Survival” 1999, vol. 41, nr 3.
Ahrari M.E., Beal J., The New Great Game in Muslim Central Asia, Honolulu 2002.
Aizhu Chen, Meng Meng, Russia Beats Saudi Arabia as China’s Top Crude Oil Supplier in 2016, Reuters, 23 I 2017, [online] http://www.reuters.com/article/us‑china‑economy-trade‑crude‑idUSKBN1570VJ.
Bartosiak J., Pacyfik i Eurazja. O wojnie, Warszawa 2016.
Bin Yu, China‑Russia, All Still Quiet in the East, „Comparative Connections” 2015, vol. 17, nr 1, [online] http://cc.csis.org/2015/05/still‑quiet‑east.
Bin Yu, Into the Syrian Storm. Between Alliance and Alignment, „Comparative Connections” 2015, vol. 17, nr 3, [online] http://cc.csis.org/2016/01/syrian‑storm‑alliance‑alignment/.
Bin Yu, Politics of „Reluctant Allies”, „Comparative Connections” 2016, vol. 18, nr 2, [online] http://cc.csis.org/2016/09/politics‑reluctant‑allies/.
Bin Yu, The Dawn of a Brave Trump World, „Comparative Connections” 2017, vol. 18, nr 3, [online] http://cc.csis.org/2017/01/dawn‑brave‑trump‑world/.
Bond I., Russia and China. Partners of Choice and Necessity?, CER Report 2016, 8 XII 2016, [online] http://www.cer.eu/sites/default/files/rpt_russia_china_8dec16_0.pdf.
Cooley A., Great Games, Local Rules. The New Great Power Contest in Central Asia, Oxford 2012.
Dacyszen W.G., Łarin W.Ł., Romanowa G.N., Zamok s granicy sniat. Prigranicznyje riegiony w rossijsko‑kitajskich otnoszenijach, [w:] Rossija i Kitaj: czetyrie wieka wzaimodiejstwija.
Dingli Shen, Russian Cooperation with China is Tactical, Not Strategic, „Global Times” 2016, 27 VI.
Gabuev A., China and Russia. Friends With Strategic Benefits, Carnegie Moscow Center, 7 IV 2017, [online] http://carnegie.ru/2017/04/07/china‑and‑russia‑friends‑with-strategic‑benefits‑pub‑68628.
Gabuev A., China’s Pivot to Putin’s Friends, „Foreign Affairs” 2016, 25 VI.
Gabuev A., Friends with Benefits? Russian‑Chinese Relations After the Ukrainian Crisis, Carnegie Moscow Center, 29 VI 2016, [online] http://carnegie.ru/2016/06/29/friends‑with‑benefits‑russian‑chinese‑relations‑after‑ukraine‑crisis‑pub‑63953.
Gabuev A., Putin‑Xi Friendship Driving Russia‑China Ties, Carnegie Moscow Center, 3 VI 2016, [online] http://carnegie.ru/2016/06/03/putin‑xi‑friendship‑driving‑russia-china‑ties‑pub‑63733.
Huang Yufan, Q. & A.: Yan Xuetong Urges China to Adopt a More Assertive Foreign Policy, „The New York Times” 2016, 9 II.
≪GAZPROM≫ i Kitaj podpisali Miemorandum o wzaimoponimanii po postawkam gaza po ≪wostocznomu≫ marszrutu, „Gazprom. Oficyalnyj sajt” 2013, 22 III.
Huasheng Zhao, Zhong’e guanxi zhibian le ma?, „Pengbo” 2016, 10 VII.
Hsiung J.C., A Re‑Appraisal of Abrahamic Values and Neorealist IR theory. From a Confucian‑Asian Perspective, [w:] China and International Relations. The Chinese View and the Contribution of Wang Gungwu, London 2010.
Intierwju Ministra inostrannych dieł Rossii S.W.Ławrowa SMI Mongolii, Japoniii KNR w prieddwierii wizitow w eti strany, Moskwa, 12 IV 2016, [online] www.mid.ru.
Istorija, sowriemiennoje sostojanije i pierspiektiwy razwitija rossijsko‑kitajskich otnoszenij, red. A.W. Łukina, Moskwa 2013.
Jakobsen L. i in., China’s Energy and Security Relations with Russia. Hopes, Frustrations and Uncertainties, „SIPRI Policy Paper” 2011, nr 29.
Johnston A.I., Cultural Realism. Strategic Culture and Grand Strategy in Chinese History, Princeton 1995.
Kaczmarski M., Rosja na rozdrożu. Polityka zagraniczna Władimira Putina, Warszawa 2006.
Kaczmarski M., Russia‑China Relations in the Post‑Crisis International Order, London 2015.
Kaczmarski M., Rodkiewicz W., Russia’s Greater Eurasia and China’s New Silk Road. Adaptation Instead of Competition, Komentarze OSW 21 VII 2016, [online] https://www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/osw‑commentary/2016‑07‑21/russias‑greater‑eurasia‑and‑chinas‑new‑silk‑road‑adaptation.
Kardaś S., Gazowe „partnerstwo wschodnie”. Kontrakt Gazpromu i CNPC na dostawy gazu do Chin, Komentarze OSW, 16 VI 2014, [online] https://www.osw.waw.pl/pl/publikacje/komentarze‑osw/2014‑06‑16/gazowe‑partnerstwo‑wschodnie‑kontrakt‑gazpromu‑i‑cnpc‑na.
≪KITAJCY ponimajut, czto Rossija diegradirujet iz‑za korrupcyi i nieeffiektiwnogo uprawlenija≫, Lenta.ru, 30 IV 2015 [online], www.lenta.ru.
Kozłowski K., Państwo Środka a Nowy Jedwabny Szlak. Proradziecka Azja Centralna i Xinjiang w polityce CHRL, Toruń 2011.
Kuleszew W. i in., O niekotorych aspiektach sowierszenstwowanija rossijsko‑kitajskogo mieżriegionalnogo sotrudniczestwa, „Problemy Dalniego Wostoka” 2010, nr 6.
Lektorij SWOP: Poczemu Rossija nikak nie możet popastʹ w Jewropu; Aleksandr Razuwajew: U Rossii jestʹ dwa dostojnych sojuznika, Vzglyad.ru, 10 VII 2015.
Lo Bobo, Russia and The New World Disorder, London 2015.
Lo Bobo, The Axis of Convenience. Moscow, Beijing, and the New Geopolitics, London–New York 2008.
Lubina M., Niedźwiedź w cieniu smoka. Rosja‑Chiny 1991‑2014, Krakow 2014.
Lubina M., Russia and China. A Political Marriage of Convenience – Stable and Successful, Opladen–Berlin–Toronto 2017.
Łarin A., Nieskolko zamieczanii o wozrożdienii Dalniego Wostoka Rossii na fonie wozrożdienmija kitajskoj nacyi, [w:] Aziatsko‑tichookieanskoje sotrudniczestwo i miesto Rossii w riegionalnom razwitii, Moskwa 2014.
Łukin A.W., Ot normalizacyi k stratiegiczeskomu partnierstwu. Rossija i Kitaj posle raspada SSSR, [w:] Rossija i Kitaj: czetyrie wieka wzaimodiejstwija. Istorija, sowriemiennoje sostojanije i pierspiektiwy razwitija rossijsko‑kitajskich otnoszenij, Moskwa 2013.
Łukin A.W., Rossija i Kitaj siegodnia i zawtra, [w:] Rossija i Kitaj: czetyrie wzaimodiejstwija. Istorija, sowriemiennoje sostojanije i pierspiektiwy razwitija rossijsko‑kitajskich otnoszenij, Moskwa 2013.
Łukjanow F., Poworot na wostok, SVOP, 15 II 2010.
Menkiszak M., Rosja wybiera Trumpa. Moskwa wobec wyborow prezydenckich w USA, Komentarze OSW, 9 XI 2016, [online] https://www.osw.waw.pl/pl/publikacje/komentarze‑osw/2016‑11‑09/rosja‑wybiera‑trumpa‑moskwa‑wobec‑wyborow‑prezydenckich‑w‑usa.
Mullerson R.A., Central Asia. A Chessboard and Player in the New Great Game, London 2014.
Nation R.C., Russia in East Asia. Aspirations and Limitations, [w:] Russia’s Prospects in Asia, red. S. Blank, Strategic Studies Institute 2010.
Nobel Winners Tell Why Russia Lacks Allure, „The Moscow Times” 2010, 21 X, [online] https://themoscowtimes.com/news/nobel‑winners‑tell‑why‑russia‑lacks‑allure‑2360.
Otwiety na woprosy żurnalistow, Kremlin.ru, 5 IX 2016, [online] http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/52834, 25 V 2018.
Pei Minxin, China and Russia: Best Frenemies Forever?, „Fortune” 2013, 28 III.
President Xi Jinping Delivers Important Speech and Proposes to Build a Silk Road Economic Belt with Central Asian Countries, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China, 7 IX 2013, [online] http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/topics_665678/xjpfwzysiesgjtfhshzzfh_665686/t1076334.shtml.
Programma sotrudniczestwa mieżdu riegionami Dalniego Wostoka i Wostocznoj Sibiri RFI Siewiero‑Wostoka KNR (2009‑2018 gody), Politiczeskoje obrazowanije.ru, 18 VII 2010.
Putin Władimir, Rossija i mieniajuszczijsia mir, Moskowskije nowosti 27 II 2012, [online], http://www.mn.ru/politics/7873.
Putin i Si Czinʹpin soszlisʹ charaktierami, Stoletije, 24 III 2013, [online] http://www.stoletie.ru/na_pervuiu_polosu/putin_i_si_czinpin_soshlis_kharakterami_746.htm.
Putin priwieł Aleksandra Niewskogo kak primier patriota, Gazeta.ru, 23 V 2011.
Qin Yaqing on Rules vs Relations, Drinking Coffee and Tea, and a Chinese Approach to Global Governance „Theory Talk #45”, [online] https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/155106/Theory%20Talk45_Yaqing.pdf.
Radi drużby Putina i Si Czinʹpina, Inosmi.ru, 17 III 2016, [online] https://inosmi.ru/politic/20160317/235747288.html.
Rapprochement or Rivalry? Russia‑China Relations in a Changing Asia, red. S.W. Garnett, Washington D.C. 2000.
Rossija prorubiła „gazowoje okno” w Aziju – błagodaria, no nie nazło Jewropie, „RIA Nowosti” 2014, 21 V.
Rozman G., The Sino‑Russian Challenge to the World Order. National Identities, Bilateral Relations, and East Versus West in the 2010s, Stanford 2014.
Russia Inks Contract with China on Su‑35 Deliveries, TASS. Russian News Agency, 19 XI 2015, [online] http://tass.ru/en/defense/837662.
≪SIŁA Sibiri≫ Jakutskij i Irkutskij centry gazodobyczi, Oil Capital.ru.
Sogłaszenije o princypach stroitielstwa i ekspłuatacyi nieftieprowoda ≪SKOWORODINO – granica s KNR≫ mieżdu Kitajskoj nacyonalnoj nieftiegazowoj korporacyjej i OAO AK ≪TRANSNIEFTʹ≫, Sowmiestnoje kommiunikie po itogam trinadcatoj riegularnoj wstrieczi gław prawitielstw KNR i RF, 29 X 2008, [online] russian.china.org.cn.
Sowmiestnaja diekłaracyja Rossijskoj Fiedieracyi i Kitajskoj Narodnoj Riespubliki, 2 XII 2002, [online] www.mid.ru.
Sowmiestnaja diekłaracyja Rossijskoj Fiedieracyi i Kitajskoj Narodnoj Riespubliki, [w:] Sbornik rossijsko‑kitajskich dogoworow 1949‑1999, Moskwa 2000.
Statja Ministra inostrannych dieł Rossii S.W. Ławrowa ≪ISTORICZESKAJA pierspiektiwa wnieszniej politiki Rossii≫, opublikowannaja w żurnale ≪ROSSIJA w głobalnoj politikie≫, 3 III 2016, [online] www.mid.ru.
Tataro‑mongolskogo iga nie było, sczitajut istoriki, Ria Novosti, 14 X 2010, [online] https://ria.ru/history_comments/20101014/285598296.html.
The Future of China‑Russia Relations, red. J. Ballacqua, Kentucky 2010.
Tisdall S., Donald Trump Attempting to Play Nixon’s „China Card” in Reverse, „The Guardian” 2016, 12 XII.
Trienin D., China’s Victory in Ukraine, „Project Syndicate” 2014, 31 VII.
Trienin D., From Greater Europe to Greater Asia? The Sino‑Russian Entente, Carnegie Moscow Center 2015, 9 IV 2015, [online] https://carnegieendowment.org/files/CP_Trenin_To_Asia_WEB_2015Eng.pdf.
Trienin D., Wiernyje druzja? Kak Rossija i Kitaj wosprinimajut drug druga, Carnegie Moscow Center, 1 VI 2012, s. 20, [online] https://carnegieendowment.org/files/CER_TreninRuss_web.pdf.
Wilson J.L., Strategic Partners. Russian‑Chinese Relations in the Post‑Soviet Era, London 2004.
Władimir Putin wypustił wostocznosibirskuju nieftʹ w morie (Vladimir Putin Released Eastern Siberian Oil into Sea), „Wiedomosti” 2009, 29 XII.
Xuetong Yan, Ancient Chinese Thought, Modern Chinese Power, Princeton 2011.
Xuetong Yan, Shijie quanli de zhuanyi. Zhengzhi lingdao yu zhanlue jingzheng (The Transition of World Power. Political Leadership and Strategic Competition), Beijing 2015.
Yan Xuetong Urges China to Adopt a More Assertive Foreign Policy, „The New York Times” 2016, 9 II.
Ying Fu, How China Sees Russia. Beijing and Moscow Are Close, but Not Allies, „Foreign Policy” 2015, 14 XII.
Yongdian Zheng, Preface, [w:] China and International Relations. The Chinese View and the Contribution of Wang Gungwu, London 2010.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2018 Politeja
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
