Is That West of Us Still the West?
A Note on the Humanist Approach to the Question of Continuity vs. Discontinuity
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12797/Politeja.15.2018.57.02Keywords:
West, humanism, discontinuity, civilizationAbstract
The article takes up the concept of “Central Eastern Europe” only to show that it makes sense if we can reshape our political imagination. What is crucial is our perception of the West which now is based on intellectual assumptions about the continuity of Western civilization. Rather, we should reflect on the role of discontinuity as the key to contemporary politics or, more broadly, to modernity. To explain this possibility, the Humanists’ (Irving Babbitt’s and Paul Elmer More’s, preceded by Thomas Hulme’s) approach is briefly surveyed, with special reference to the question of civilization vs. barbarism as the most relevant, or most urgent, distinction in the modern world. The main message is that we, the “Central Eastern Europeans,” are very much in need of political realism. This ought to be, however, a type of realism based on profound philosophical insight, like that of the Humanists.
Downloads
PlumX Metrics of this article
References
Babbitt I., Democracy and Leadership, Indianapolis 1979.
Google Scholar
Babbitt I., “Humanism: An Essay at Definition”, in N. Foerster (ed.), Humanism and America: Essays on the Outlook of Modern Civilization, New York 1930.
Google Scholar
Babbitt I., “Humanistic Education in China and the West”, The Chinese Students’ Monthly, vol. 17, no. 2 (December 1921).
Google Scholar
Babbitt I., “Interpreting India to the West”, in I. Babbitt, F. Manchester, F. Giese, W.F. Giese (eds.), Spanish Character and Other Essays, Boston–New York 1940.
Google Scholar
Babbitt I., Literature and the American College: Essays in Defense of the Humanities, Boston–New York 1908.
Google Scholar
Babbitt I., Rousseau and Romanticism, Boston–New York 1919.
Google Scholar
Babbitt I., “What I Believe: Rousseau and Religion”, in I. Babbitt, F. Manchester, F. Giese, W.F. Giese (eds.), Spanish Character and Other Essays, Boston–New York 1940.
Google Scholar
Hulme T.E., Read H., Speculations: Essays on Humanism and the Philosophy of Art, London–New York 1936.
Google Scholar
Lippmann W., Public Opinion, New York 1997.
Google Scholar
More P.E., “Academic Leadership”, in P.E. More, Shelburne Essays Ninth Series: Aristocracy and Justice, Boston–New York 1915.
Google Scholar
More P.E., “Definitions of Dualism”, in P.E. More, Shelburne Essays Eighth Series: The Drift of Romanticism, New York–Boston.
Google Scholar
More P.E., Harris C.M., The Jessica Letters, An Editor’s Romance, New York–London 1904.
Google Scholar
More P.E., “Rousseau”, in P.E. More, Shelburne Essays Sixth Series: Studies of Religious Dualism, New York–London 1909.
Google Scholar
More P.E., The Christ of the New Testament, Princeton 1924.
Google Scholar
More P.E., The Demon of The Absolute (New Shelburne Essays I), Princeton 1928.
Google Scholar
More P.E., The Religion of Plato, Princeton–London 1921.
Google Scholar
More P.E., “The Religious Ground of Humanitarianism”, in P.E. More, Shelburne Essays First Series, New York–London 1904.
Google Scholar
More P.E., “Tolstoy; Or, the Ancient Feud Between Philosophy and Art”, in P.E. More, Shelburne Essays First Series, New York–London 1904.
Google Scholar
Murry J.M., The Evolution of an Intellectual, New York 1920.
Google Scholar
Strauss L., “Social Science and Humanism”, in L. Strauss, Th.L. Pangle, The Rebirth of Classical Political Rationalism: An Introduction to the Thought of Leo Strauss, Chicago–London 1989.
Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2018 Paweł Armada
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
